←back to thread

The Claude Code Framework Wars

(shmck.substack.com)
125 points ShMcK | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.203s | source
Show context
troupo ◴[] No.45156574[source]
> a set of rules, roles, and workflows that make its output predictable and valuable.

Let me stop you right there. Are you seriously talking about predictable when talking about a non-deterministic black box over which you have no control?

replies(6): >>45156592 #>>45156630 #>>45156764 #>>45156773 #>>45158223 #>>45159030 #
andsoitis ◴[] No.45156592[source]
> Are you seriously talking about predictable when talking about a non-deterministic

Predictability and determinism are related but different concepts.

A system can be predictable in a probabilistic sense, rather than an exact, deterministic one. This means that while you may not be able to predict the precise outcome of a single event, you can accurately forecast the overall behavior of the system and the likelihood of different outcomes.

https://philosophy.stackexchange.com/questions/96145/determi...

Similarly, a system can be deterministic yet unpredictable due to practical limitations like sensitivity to initial conditions (chaos theory), lack of information, or the inability to compute predictions in time.

replies(2): >>45156775 #>>45156812 #
1. troupo ◴[] No.45156812[source]
From the discussion in the link: "Predictability means that you can figure out what will happen next based on what happened previously."

Having used nearly all of the methods in the original article, I can predict that the output of the model is nearly indistinguishable from a coin toss for many, many, many rather obvious reasons.