←back to thread

I kissed comment culture goodbye

(sustainableviews.substack.com)
256 points spyckie2 | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source | bottom
Show context
neko_ranger ◴[] No.45143740[source]
I find typing the comment out, then deleting it and not submitting kinda gives my brain the 90% feeling of needing to say something. Only place I don't have to do this is 4chan, where the worst thing to happen is that your comment gets ignored or something mean is said to me (oh dear!)

I unironically just closed this tab before submitting out of habit and reopened it to submit this

replies(5): >>45143763 #>>45143808 #>>45143829 #>>45144008 #>>45144152 #
1. eterm ◴[] No.45143763[source]
I've found increasingly I'll submit a comment only to go back 30 seconds later and delete it.
replies(5): >>45143793 #>>45144005 #>>45144175 #>>45144180 #>>45144339 #
2. anyfoo ◴[] No.45143793[source]
I mostly do that when I go "that was a little bit mean of me... do I really need to be mean, what's the point?"

Fortunately, that seems to also have trained me to not write those comments in the first place. I also think much more about what I am trying to actually effect with a comment, not just about what feels good in the particular moment.

One thing that didn't change though is that probably most of my comments are edited at least once, often a few times, right after sending them. And even if it's just swapping out a word, or adding a missing comma. This one here is no exception at all, I just added this paragraph after doing some minor edits.

3. abruzzi ◴[] No.45144005[source]
I participate in a number of 'old school' forums, never anything like reddit or discord. On those forums, while I have posted on some a fair amount, I actually find that most of the time I spend 15 minutes writing up a post, then delete it. There are a number of reasons I don't hit the submit button. Sometimes its because I see that a lot of other posters will disagree with it, and I don't think they will argue rationally and in good faith; but the most valuable posts I don't submit are when I get to a point in my argument when I realize that I'm wrong or that my opinion or point of view is badly supported or any numer of other things that force me to re-evaluate position. I've probably held that position for a while thinking I'm right, but actually formulating the argument forces me to confront my biases or mistakes.
replies(1): >>45144822 #
4. ◴[] No.45144175[source]
5. octo888 ◴[] No.45144180[source]
[deleted]
6. EvanAnderson ◴[] No.45144339[source]
Glad to hear I'm not the only one. I've been doing that a ton on HN lately.
7. csin ◴[] No.45144822[source]
Sounds like forums are your rubber ducky debugger of life.