←back to thread

463 points bookofjoe | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
urban_winter ◴[] No.45135502[source]
This is just a dedicated RF emitter combined with a dedicated receiver. The fact that is it uses WiFi hardware is probably just because that's the cheapest and most available hardware for the researcher to work with. There is no indication in the article that the WiFi can actually be used for transmitting real data at the same time; that a non-dedicated WiFi source can be used; that it works when there are many people between transmitter and receiver.

Therefore the ideas that this might apply to real-world situations and use existing WiFi infrastructure, are a stretch given the information that's been shared.

It basically doesn't seem like a big deal to demonstrate what has been demonstrated.

replies(2): >>45136727 #>>45137669 #
boxed ◴[] No.45137669[source]
> This is just a dedicated RF emitter combined with a dedicated receiver. The fact that is it uses WiFi hardware is probably just because that's the cheapest and most available hardware for the researcher to work with.

Ok.

> There is no indication in the article that the WiFi can actually be used for transmitting real data at the same time

So? No one said it was.

> Therefore the ideas that this might apply to real-world situations and use existing WiFi infrastructure, are a stretch given the information that's been shared.

What? First you say it's trivial/obvious, and now it's impossible? Decide on your critique.

replies(1): >>45138020 #
urban_winter ◴[] No.45138020[source]
The dominant themes in the thread relate to using existing WiFi infrastructure in real world environments. I thought it would be obvious that I was critiquing this line of thinking. Obviously not.
replies(1): >>45138135 #
1. transpute ◴[] No.45138135[source]
Real-world applications benefit from recent on-device hardware like NPU or Apple Neural Engine.

Intel demo on commercial laptop (2022), https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45130061

Qualcomm human-in-home positioning demo (2021), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNmnqCsvMTU