←back to thread

598 points leotravis10 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.242s | source
Show context
bawolff ◴[] No.45129304[source]
There has been this trend recently of calling Wikipedia the last good thing on the internet.

And i agree its great, i spend an inordinate amount of my time on Wikimedia related things.

But i think there is a danger here with all these articles putting Wikipedia too much on a pedestal. It isn't perfect. It isn't perfectly neutral or perfectly reliable. It has flaws.

The true best part of Wikipedia is that its a work in progress and people are working to make it a little better everyday. We shouldn't lose sight of the fact we aren't there yet. We'll never be "there". But hopefully we'll continue to be a little bit closer every day. And that is what makes Wikipedia great.

replies(28): >>45129452 #>>45129539 #>>45130082 #>>45130452 #>>45130510 #>>45130655 #>>45130889 #>>45131753 #>>45132388 #>>45133857 #>>45134041 #>>45134322 #>>45134802 #>>45135047 #>>45135272 #>>45135426 #>>45135634 #>>45135865 #>>45135925 #>>45136197 #>>45136339 #>>45136658 #>>45137707 #>>45139242 #>>45140012 #>>45140417 #>>45140938 #>>45148201 #
mdp2021 ◴[] No.45129539[source]
It's a miracle that the model of voluntary contribution from random agents and imperfect overview partially worked.

The science that could emerge by studying the phenomenon could constitute a milestone.

replies(4): >>45129902 #>>45130002 #>>45130399 #>>45131390 #
e3bc54b2 ◴[] No.45130399[source]
The zeroeth law of Wikipedia – The problem with Wikipedia is that it only works in practice. In theory, it can never work.
replies(3): >>45130531 #>>45132399 #>>45134751 #
IAmBroom ◴[] No.45130531[source]
Clever. I had to read that repeatedly to get it.

Cf: The difference between theory and practice is: "Practice works, in theory."

replies(3): >>45131764 #>>45132404 #>>45134803 #
alpaca128 ◴[] No.45131764[source]
I heard it as "in theory, theory and practice are the same"
replies(1): >>45134237 #
1. Izkata ◴[] No.45134237[source]
I've heard that style too, with the addendum "in practice, not".