←back to thread

156 points xbmcuser | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.376s | source
Show context
taeric ◴[] No.45127622[source]
This feels misleading to me.

I accept that data centers generate more load for a system. Which will make the overall system need more maintenance, which is something that others paying into the system will also have to support. But, I'm not clear on why this is a hidden cost.

Consider, if people get the new housing developments that they want, that would also add load to the system. This larger energy system will be more expensive to run, which will lead to higher costs. Adding houses would probably be even more expensive in the transmission maintenance costs associated.

Any model you do that tries to prevent this is essentially rent stabilization for early members. And that has a pretty good track record of not being a good idea.

replies(10): >>45127808 #>>45127833 #>>45127981 #>>45128046 #>>45128049 #>>45128072 #>>45128295 #>>45128361 #>>45129790 #>>45130643 #
minraws ◴[] No.45128072[source]
Now let's consider a different form of govt/shared charges.

Taxes, why are individual and corporate taxes and structures different?

Both are doing work and generating income?

Why do corporations get to deductions and do so much tax magic that individuals don't?

why don't we charge them both with the same laws, and structures?

Cause corporates generate jobs? Isn't that unfair to the people born individuals...

I don't think anyone is saying there should be stabilization of electricity prices. But costs for grid improvements for industrial, data center or AI usage should be on the said companies.

They are using that resource to generate a profit.

While people in residential homes are just living their lives, you are comparing cost of essential commodities to production inputs...

We make taxes on poorer people less as well for the same reason.

But yes if someone is saying electricity prices should be stabilized for early consumers that's definitely unfair. But I didn't see or read that here.

replies(2): >>45128366 #>>45138978 #
1. gruez ◴[] No.45128366[source]
>Why do corporations get to deductions and do so much tax magic that individuals don't?

Individuals can do deductions if they're a sole proprietorship. The requirement in general is that the expense is used for a business purpose. Buying a laptop for personal consumption isn't tax deductible, but buying it for your consulting business is.

replies(2): >>45131065 #>>45134833 #
2. ◴[] No.45131065[source]
3. minraws ◴[] No.45134833[source]
Isn't that proving my point you change laws based on what you do with your money and where you get it from.

If so data centers should also be separately booked for their electricity consumption.