←back to thread

30 minutes with a stranger

(pudding.cool)
1103 points MaxLeiter | 2 comments | 04 Sep 25 05:56 UTC | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
pavlov ◴[04 Sep 25 07:20 UTC] No.45124523[source]▶
Really great design.

This is the unicorn of fancy websites because for once, it actually makes sense to override browser's standard scrolling behavior. The 30-minute timeline on the right provides an obvious context for what you're navigating with the scroll actions, and you wouldn't be able to do that with a regular scrollbar.

Usually scrolling overrides happen because the designers' mindset was that the site should be a sequence of beautiful slides. They might prototype it as a Keynote presentation that is approved by management. And then some poor web developer gets tasked with building a site that feels like the Keynote slide show that everyone loved, and the only way to do that is to turn scrolling into an annoying "next slide" action.

replies(7): >>45124684 #>>45124958 #>>45125016 #>>45125031 #>>45125249 #>>45125991 #>>45188373 #
1. rkagerer ◴[04 Sep 25 08:23 UTC] No.45124958[source]▶
I don't mind designers overriding when they take meticulous care to craft a better tailored experience. But once I scrolled past the initial content I found the site a UI disaster. Not long after it said "Pick a person to explore", I wanted to tap a particular box to read one of their conversations, and couldn't figure out how to bring any dialog up. I wound up scrolling further down afterward to see if that was how to trigger some dialog for my selection, and all the boxes started moving around at seemingly random, performance tanked and the whole thing got stuttery. I couldn't scroll back to where I was or find that box again that I was interested in. I left in frustration. Design fail, as far as this user's encounter.
replies(1): >>45126386 #
2. deathlock ◴[04 Sep 25 12:16 UTC] No.45126386[source]▶
I feel the same. I don't particularly mind if a developer overrides the scrollbar, and I would actually argue that in this case it was a good way to present the story and overall I liked it, but you need to do it right. If the sites becomes all clunky, it stutters, and you get text popping up a while after you scrolled, then it's better to focus on the performance and leave aside the animations.