←back to thread

677 points meetpateltech | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
ppeetteerr ◴[] No.45118464[source]
I love Zed and I'm glad you now have native support for Claude. I previously ran it using the instructions in this post: https://benswift.me/blog/2025/07/23/running-claude-code-with...

One thing that still suffers is AI autocomplete. While I tried Zed's own solution and supermaven (now part of Cursor), I still find Cursor's AI autocomplete and predictions much more accurate (even pulling up a file via search is more accurate in Cursor).

I am glad to hear that Zed got a round of funding. https://zed.dev/blog/sequoia-backs-zed This will go a long way to creating real competition to Cursor in the form of a quality IDE not built on VSCode

replies(9): >>45118738 #>>45118799 #>>45119067 #>>45119080 #>>45120139 #>>45120380 #>>45121210 #>>45121710 #>>45126045 #
cnqso ◴[] No.45118799[source]
What Zed lacks in code generation quality it makes up for in not-being-an-Electron-app
replies(6): >>45118850 #>>45119433 #>>45119652 #>>45119863 #>>45121653 #>>45123340 #
llbbdd ◴[] No.45119863[source]
Every single new HN thread should come with an automod post badmouthing Electron to save everyone time.
replies(1): >>45122458 #
dcreater ◴[] No.45122458[source]
its a bad anti-pattern that trades developer convenience for performance, UX etc. Its fair to hate on it

With the advent of coding agents, I really hope we see devs move away - back to the traditional approach of using native frameworks/languages as now, you can write for 1 platform and easily task AI to handle other platforms.

replies(2): >>45123484 #>>45123900 #
llbbdd ◴[] No.45123900{3}[source]
This will never happen and it's a bizarre, legacy fantasy, borne of a fixed imaginary ideal of what computing should be. Programming will continue to move in the direction of ease-of-use and every time I see an out-of-topic reference to Electron in this forum I feel insane, like I'm fighting upstream. You will not see this - you will see more Electron apps, because that is the modern way of building cross-platform apps, and if you genuinely don't understand why that is I don't know how to explain it to you. You won't see another version of those because nobody is going to waste their time building cross-platform native apps at a native layer to performatively impress posters on HN. You, and seemingly everybody else on HN, can continue to pretend that devex doesn't matter, but that's the difference I guess between caring about devex and shipping products.
replies(3): >>45124104 #>>45126934 #>>45131953 #
arianvanp ◴[] No.45124104{4}[source]
It's not out of topic. We're discussing the Zed editor. Their whole marketing ploy is "we are not electron", "we are rust", "we are native", "we are not slow" alternative to VScode.

This is literally their whole distinguishing feature and people are switching because of it and just it.

replies(1): >>45124164 #
1. llbbdd ◴[] No.45124164{5}[source]
It is! If the thing runs like shit, say it runs like shit. Say it's native or not, like every topic title and comment on HN until we weep of boredom. I know it's rust! everything is rust here! Is there any other reason I should care? Are we a forum for discussing interesting technology or are we a forum for discussing alternatives to VSCode? And again, who is switching? People shipping products or HN posters with their dumb metrics?
replies(1): >>45124896 #
2. arianvanp ◴[] No.45124896[source]
People who install zed are switching. I don't understand what you're trying to "get" at. You're complaining about people talking about Zed in a topic about Zed.

Zed seems to have been hugely succesful recently and their only real distinguishing feature is "fast from the ground up". It has less features than vscode. Worse AI features than Cursor. but people seem to love it nonetheless.

Turns out there is a market for people fed up with VScode-derivatives.