←back to thread

184 points Bogdanp | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.206s | source
Show context
alphazard ◴[] No.45105959[source]
Unfortunately the tech community is full of people who pride themselves on being aware of and advocating for the latest standard put out by whatever company. That's how we end up with lots of complicated nonsense like most of what is sent in HTTP headers, or the contents of a TLS certificate.

On the topic of authentication, it's solved. SSH nailed it, any further complexity is strictly worse. Signing up is uploading a public key. Signing in is cryptographically signing a commitment to the current ephemeral tunnel.

replies(10): >>45106121 #>>45106140 #>>45106170 #>>45106176 #>>45106183 #>>45106261 #>>45106406 #>>45106911 #>>45107421 #>>45107745 #
palata ◴[] No.45107421[source]
> On the topic of authentication, it's solved. SSH nailed it, any further complexity is strictly worse.

Ever tried to SSH with a security key... through FIDO2? Or would you say that having your private key as a file on your computer is strictly better than having it in a security key? :-)

replies(1): >>45123281 #
1. AnnualDegree99 ◴[] No.45123281[source]
I use this very setup, it works great. Yubikey has supported resident keys for a while.