←back to thread

229 points geetee | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
tgv ◴[] No.45100192[source]
This makes little sense to me. Ontologies and all that have been tried and have always been found to be too brittle. Take the examples from the front page (which I expect to be among the best in their set): human_activity => climate_change. Those are such a broad concepts that it's practically useless. Or disease => death. There's no nuance at all. There isn't even a definition of what "disease" is, let alone a way to express that myxomatosis is lethal for only European rabbits, not humans, nor gold fish.
replies(15): >>45100256 #>>45100368 #>>45100385 #>>45100399 #>>45100512 #>>45100673 #>>45100711 #>>45100804 #>>45101092 #>>45101484 #>>45103042 #>>45103397 #>>45104046 #>>45108308 #>>45114204 #
tossandthrow ◴[] No.45100399[source]
Ontology, not ontologies, have been tried.

We have quite a good understanding that a system cannot be both sound a complete, regardless people went straight in to make a single model of the world.

replies(3): >>45101077 #>>45101306 #>>45104682 #
kachnuv_ocasek ◴[] No.45101306[source]
> a system cannot be both sound a complete

Huh, what do you mean by this? There are many sound and complete systems – propositional logic, first-order logic, Presburger arithmetic, the list goes on. These are the basic properties you want from a logical or typing system. (Though, of course, you may compromise if you have other priorities.)

replies(3): >>45101505 #>>45103901 #>>45124177 #
lemonwaterlime ◴[] No.45101505[source]
My take is that the GP was implicitly referring to Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorems with the implication being that a system that reasons completely about all the human topics and itself is not possible. Therefore, you’d need multiple such systems (plural) working in concert.
replies(3): >>45101729 #>>45102980 #>>45106128 #
eru ◴[] No.45101729{3}[source]
That doesn't make much sense.

If you take multiple systems and make them work in concert, you just get a bigger system.

replies(3): >>45101809 #>>45103157 #>>45103427 #
tossandthrow ◴[] No.45101809{4}[source]
Concerts - again plural. And naturally you only bring in appropriate instruments.
replies(1): >>45103806 #
1. svnt ◴[] No.45103806{5}[source]
Turtles all the way down?