←back to thread

2071 points K0nserv | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
tzury ◴[] No.45088695[source]
We need both options to coexist:

1. Open, hackable hardware for those who want full control and for driving innovation

2. Locked-down, managed devices for vulnerable users who benefit from protection

This concept of "I should run any code on hardware I own" is completely wrong as a universal principle. Yes, we absolutely should be able to run any code we want on open hardware we own - that option must exist. But we should not expect manufacturers of phones and tablets to allow anyone to run any code on every device, since this will cause harm to many users.

There should be more open and hackable products available in the market. The DIY mindset at the junction of hardware and software is crucial for tech innovation - we wouldn't be where we are today without it. However, I also want regulations and restrictions on the phones I buy for my kids and grandparents. They need protection from themselves and from bad actors.

The market should serve both groups: those who want to tinker and innovate, and those who need a safe, managed experience. The problem isn't that locked-down devices exist - it's that we don't have enough truly open alternatives for those who want them.

replies(23): >>45088735 #>>45088761 #>>45088840 #>>45088846 #>>45088867 #>>45088917 #>>45088924 #>>45088947 #>>45089091 #>>45089098 #>>45089274 #>>45089445 #>>45089853 #>>45090037 #>>45090783 #>>45091788 #>>45091834 #>>45092235 #>>45092332 #>>45092365 #>>45092417 #>>45092508 #>>45094664 #
beeflet ◴[] No.45089853[source]
Do we need the second option to exist? The world is dangerous place. If you can't figure out a computer perhaps you're just unfit to participate in the modern economy.

The existence of locked-down hardware eliminates the feasibility of open hardware through network effects. That is what is happening now.

replies(1): >>45089891 #
Jolter ◴[] No.45089891[source]
You realize you’re discounting 98% of the world’s population, right?
replies(3): >>45089967 #>>45090432 #>>45094706 #
1. fragmede ◴[] No.45090432[source]
I think you just made up that number.
replies(1): >>45090774 #
2. Jolter ◴[] No.45090774[source]
I did! You’re welcome to make your own estimate of how many people are able to correctly judge when snd what software is safe to install on their phone.