←back to thread

215 points XzetaU8 | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
dsign ◴[] No.45080365[source]
I was walking on the street the other day. It was fine summer, and I saw so many elderly walking outside. All of them were using one type of aid or another; some even had a social worker at their side. As I saw them, I was thinking that my 63% marginal tax was paying for it, while I part with 25% of my income after taxes to pay my mom’s pension. That monetary cost is nothing, I would gladly pay it for the rest of my life if it could give my mom a good life for that long. Her old age is my single biggest source of stress.

In the political sphere, some countries are tearing themselves apart on the question of immigration and identity. But immigration is the only thing that can replenish their workforce.

So, we are paying an extremely high cost for letting God go on with His Slow Tormentous Cooking of Souls before Consumption, and things are only going to get worse, given the demographic expectations. Wouldn’t it make sense to put a big chunk of budget into creating life-extension tech?

replies(11): >>45080620 #>>45080726 #>>45080845 #>>45080929 #>>45081090 #>>45081233 #>>45081964 #>>45082340 #>>45082530 #>>45084648 #>>45085107 #
simianparrot ◴[] No.45080845[source]
> But immigration is the only thing that can replenish their workforce.

Unchecked immigration of people who do not share the majority of the destination’s cultural values leads to a monoculture that is terrible for everyone. Multiculturalism doesn’t work when everyone’s culture is equal everywhere. And unless it wasn’t obvious, I firmly believe in multiculturalism, but I believe we (here in Europe in particular) have been misled about what it should look like. And no it’s not about ethnicity.

And that’s saying nothing about the impact on source countries as some other comments go into.

replies(3): >>45080887 #>>45081215 #>>45081464 #
oezi ◴[] No.45080887[source]
As another European I don't understand your argument because Europe has seen so much internal migration over the hundreds of years that it is weird to argue it is leading to monoculture.

Also unchecked migration to Europe is down to 200.000 people per year so less than 0.1% of population.

replies(2): >>45080940 #>>45083412 #
simianparrot ◴[] No.45080940{3}[source]
I include poor vetting and integration as unchecked immigration if that wasn’t obvious. And do note that I wrote

> people who do not share the majority of the destination’s cultural values

No culture should nor can stay stagnant. But if we allow in people who do not share or wish to share a majority of our cultural values, which vary a lot between European countries as well, then we deteriorate what made our countries lucrative destinations for these people faster than we can maintain it.

It’s not complicated. Why are all those people coming here if all cultures are equal?

replies(3): >>45081080 #>>45082933 #>>45083121 #
1. YeGoblynQueenne ◴[] No.45082933{4}[source]
That's a great soundbite but if you asked e.g. the average British person just before Brexit they'd tell you that they are worried about all the Poles, Bulgarians and Romanians, i.e. other Europeans, coming here, taking our jobs, scrounging wellfare and so on.

I mean, realistically speaking, they'd be bitching about Pakistanis and Indians and Middle Eastern immigrants also, but in 2016 the British voted to exit the European Union, not the Middle Eastern Union. The hint is right there, in the name.

replies(1): >>45083456 #
2. nradov ◴[] No.45083456[source]
Right, and now UK voters are increasingly opposed to immigration from India, Nigeria, and China. The UK government allowed a large increase in legal immigration, particularly to find more elder care workers. But that appears to be causing a backlash.

https://www.wsj.com/world/uk/britain-farage-migration-debacl...

replies(2): >>45083940 #>>45088677 #
3. Sharlin ◴[] No.45083940[source]
Certainly an interesting source of cognitive dissonance. Few would admit it, but in practice I can see many people feeling more strongly about foreigners than humane care for the elderly (we've alredy done a good job at putting them out of sight, out of mind!)
4. HDThoreaun ◴[] No.45088677[source]
Maybe the UK voters are idiots who dont learn from their mistakes?