←back to thread

You Have to Feel It

(mitchellh.com)
376 points tosh | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.407s | source
Show context
mcdeltat ◴[] No.45078646[source]
I've learnt that just about everything in life boils down to feelings, which is interesting. No matter how rational a person or people claim to be, usually it comes down to feelings... Life choices? Business decisions? Who gets promoted? It's all vibes and feelings. People will deliberate and argue over facts but ultimately there will be some "weighting" factor which is feelings and will make or break the outcome. You can have a perfectly argued decision that fails some vibe check and is hence discarded. Or a terrible argument that plays to some emotional point so is accepted. It's all feelings. Rare is the opposite.
replies(12): >>45078785 #>>45078868 #>>45079484 #>>45079722 #>>45079897 #>>45080295 #>>45080735 #>>45083072 #>>45083193 #>>45083907 #>>45084333 #>>45084578 #
hakunin ◴[] No.45080735[source]
I grew to believe that feelings have hard-to-recognize rationales that can be explained if you dig deep enough. Very few people ever do however. Recognizing the rationale is a great skill to have in many circumstances where you give feedback, like code reviews for example. It's also a skill that makes you a better teacher.
replies(2): >>45081787 #>>45082793 #
1. pfannkuchen ◴[] No.45081787[source]
I’m on board with the idea here, but the way you worded it makes it sound like “rationalizing” which is generally considered harmful.

Is this different from rationalizing? Or are we saying that rationalizing is okay if you are sufficiently attuned to your feelings?

replies(1): >>45082585 #
2. LoganDark ◴[] No.45082585[source]
I get the impression you're using 'rationalizing' to mean finding a reason for an emotion that doesn't necessarily match the true source of the emotion. This is different from recognizing the existing rationale, which is exactly why it's generally considered harmful. If one gets in the habit of finding new rationales for their emotions that sound more favorable, they can also get in the habit of no longer keeping their true rationales in check, which I would assume tends to result in sociopathic behavior.