Cognitive load is what matters

This was my main takeaway from A Philosophy Of Software Design by John Ousterhout. It is the best book on this subject and I recommend it to every software developer.

Basically, you should aim to minimise complexity in software design, but importantly, complexity is defined as "how difficult is it to make changes to it". "How difficult" is largely determined by the amount of cognitive load necessary to understand it.

Which is why I consider DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself) to be an anti-rule until an application is fairly well understood and multiple versions exist. DO repeat yourself, and do not create some smart version of what you think the problem is before you're attempting the 3rd version. Version 1 is how you figure out the problem space, version 2 is how you figure out your solution as a maintainable dynamic thing within a changing tech landscape, and version 3 is when DRY is look at for the first time for that application.

DRY isn't about not reimplementing things; it's about not literally copying and pasting code. Which I have seen all the time, and which some might find easier now but will definitely make the system harder to change (correctly) at some point later on.

I’ll bite. We’re expanding into Europe. I literally copied and pasted our entire infrastructure into a new folder named “Europe”

Now there’s a new requirement that only applies to Europe and nowhere else and it’s super easy and straight forward to change the infrastructure.

I don’t see how it was a poor choice to literally copy and paste configs that result in hundreds of thousands of lines of yaml and I have 25 yoe.