←back to thread

215 points XzetaU8 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
simianparrot ◴[] No.45080875[source]
The assumption that everything can be “fixed” is one I will never understand. It’s so obvious when studying organisms in all their shapes and forms how everything is a tradeoff, and nothing can be stable. The fundamental truth of the universe is change.

Senescence is a tradeoff to ward against cancer earlier in life. Eventually it will lead to cancer as a side effect, but optimally something else has failed before then. You can’t patch it out completely without breaking something else.

replies(5): >>45080934 #>>45081036 #>>45081242 #>>45081247 #>>45083307 #
nojs ◴[] No.45080934[source]
This is a catch-all dismissal that you could make about any medical innovation throughout history. There are a lot of things we can fix, and we’ve had a lot of success so far in doing so.
replies(1): >>45080958 #
simianparrot ◴[] No.45080958[source]
It’s not. We never fix anything in medicine: We treat and prevent. Removing the appendix prevents or treats acute appendicitis, but it also has a tradeoff in terms of removing a gut biome reservoir.

This isn’t me dismissing the incredible improvements to our way of life modern medicine has brought. In essence it’s given everyone access to the same potential standard of living as was reserved for kings and nobility in the past — and then some.

But you can’t fully fix aging. You can’t infinitely improve standard of living.

replies(3): >>45081024 #>>45084900 #>>45100202 #
ACCount37 ◴[] No.45081024[source]
Not if you throw your hands up and never try!

Aging isn't even recognized as a disease yet, and it well should be. Once it gets at least the same kind of focus cancer or heart disease does now? Then we'll talk about how it's "impossible to fix".

replies(2): >>45081075 #>>45081092 #
1. baq ◴[] No.45081075{3}[source]
Aging is a disease in the same way children are parasites. Fix one, fix the other.