Cognitive load is what matters

It's always interesting that many people who push the cognitive load argument also push for simpler languages. To me once I have learned a language well the features it has don't add to the cognitive load. they become basically second nature. It even has a great benefit, many things that are explicit in simple languages because there is no language support fall away in more complex languages. So more complex languages reduce cognitive load, at least for me.

Complex languages can give the programmer powerful tools to abstract things badly. But those powerful tools can also help make the code clearer if used right. (I'm a real sucker for a map().filter().map().sort().unwrap(), and feel the same logic becomes so unruly to understand if converted to a large loop)

I think the sentiment that we should use simpler languages comes abuse of powerful features. Once we've meta-programmed the entire program logic with a 12 layer deep type tree or inheritance chain... we may realize we abused the tool in a way a simple language would have stopped.

But at the same time...checking a errno() after a function call just because the language lack result type or exception handling, is clearly too simple. A minor increase in language complexity would have made the code much clearer.

Exactly, cognitive load is dynamic not static, and you can actually hold many more things in working memory than the oft-repeated 3-7 items (that's more if you're trying memorize and recall unrelated, novel items).

Once you commit a particular concept to long-term memory and it's not "leaky" (you have to think through the internal behavior/implementation details), then now you have more tools and ways to describe a collective bunch of lower-level concepts.

That's the same feeling programmers used to more powerful languages have to write less powerful languages — instead of using 1 concept to describe what you want, now you have to use multiple things. It's only easier if you've not grokked the concept.

>So more complex languages reduce cognitive load, at least for me.

Even C++ and all it's crazy features of last 5-10 years?