←back to thread

454 points positiveblue | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.224s | source
1. calmbonsai ◴[] No.45068770[source]
While I concur with the effective tech, I don't think this is something that's a net win for society.

Just because you can, doesn't mean you should and I don't feel any one entity (private or public) should be an arbiter on these matters.

This is something that can, and should, be negotiated at the "last virtual mile".

replies(2): >>45070277 #>>45073381 #
2. positiveblue ◴[] No.45070277[source]
100% needs to be done at the last mile.
3. rs_rs_rs_rs_rs ◴[] No.45073381[source]
>Just because you can, doesn't mean you should and I don't feel any one entity (private or public) should be an arbiter on these matters.

What do you mean by private? Should I not be allowed to block AI agents on my sites using Cloudflare?

replies(1): >>45088197 #
4. calmbonsai ◴[] No.45088197[source]
More precisely, Cloudflare should not be able to offer this service. AI agents should be blocked at the hosted API endpoint ("last mile"), not at a CDN or other sort of intermediary.

That said, if you're using Cloudflare Workers, where the endpoint itself is hosted by Cloudflare, that would be ethical.

replies(1): >>45088274 #
5. kentonv ◴[] No.45088274{3}[source]
If the CDN is implementing the explicitly-configured preferences of the specific site, what difference does it make if the blocking happens at the CDN vs. the site's origin server?