←back to thread

747 points porridgeraisin | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.255s | source
Show context
Syzygies ◴[] No.45063736[source]
Claude assists me in my math research.

The scenario that concerns me is that Claude learns unpublished research ideas from me as we chat and code. Claude then suggests these same ideas to someone else, who legitimately believes this is now their work.

Clearly commercial accounts use AI to assist in developing intellectual product, and privacy is mandatory. The same can apply to individuals.

replies(9): >>45063744 #>>45064034 #>>45064105 #>>45064140 #>>45064248 #>>45064416 #>>45064428 #>>45065522 #>>45065601 #
vdfs ◴[] No.45064034[source]
> Claude assists me in my math research.

> Claude then suggests these same ideas to someone else, who legitimately believes this is now their work.

Won't this mean that claude assisted you with someone else work? Sure it's not from a "chat" but claude doesn't really know anything other than it's training data

replies(3): >>45064395 #>>45064437 #>>45066937 #
iaw ◴[] No.45064395[source]
> claude doesn't really know anything other than it's training data

I've seen cases where Claude demonstrates novel behaviors or combines existing concepts in new ways based on my input. I don't think it's as simple as memorization anymore.

replies(1): >>45064788 #
1. ffsm8 ◴[] No.45064788[source]
If I am standing in Finland and look out on the ocean, and the whole sky is green... Is the sky actually green?

You're equating your own perspective as objective truth, which is a very common pitfall and fallacy