←back to thread

747 points porridgeraisin | 10 comments | | HN request time: 0.003s | source | bottom
Show context
troad ◴[] No.45062852[source]
You can opt out, but the fact that it's opt-in by default and made to look like a simple T/C update prompt leaves a sour taste in my mouth. The five year retention period seems... excessive. I wonder if they've buried anything else objectionable in the new terms.

It was the kick in the pants I needed to cancel my subscription.

replies(22): >>45062875 #>>45062894 #>>45062895 #>>45062930 #>>45062936 #>>45062949 #>>45062975 #>>45063015 #>>45063070 #>>45063116 #>>45063150 #>>45063171 #>>45063186 #>>45063387 #>>45063615 #>>45064792 #>>45064955 #>>45064986 #>>45064996 #>>45066593 #>>45070194 #>>45074231 #
1. wzdd ◴[] No.45063070[source]
Everywhere else in Anthropic's interface, yes/no switches show blue when enabled and black when disabled. In the box they're showing about this change the slider shows grey in both states: visit it in preferences to see the difference! It's not just disappointing but also kind of sad that someone went to the effort to do this.
replies(3): >>45063117 #>>45063179 #>>45065374 #
2. riz_ ◴[] No.45063117[source]
This is probably because there are laws in some countries that restrict how these buttons/switches can look (think cookie banners, where sometimes there is a huge green button to accept, and a tiny greyed out text somewhere for the settings).
replies(1): >>45064227 #
3. senko ◴[] No.45063179[source]
Just did and it behaves as expected for me in the Android app (ie. not the dark pattern you described)
replies(1): >>45064551 #
4. soulofmischief ◴[] No.45064227[source]
Can you provide an example?
replies(1): >>45064505 #
5. riz_ ◴[] No.45064505{3}[source]
https://www.cnil.fr/en/dark-patterns-cookie-banners-cnil-iss...
replies(1): >>45066715 #
6. BalinKing ◴[] No.45064551[source]
I can confirm it's grey on both sides on the website.
replies(1): >>45065542 #
7. Aurornis ◴[] No.45065374[source]
It works correctly (blue on, grey off) in the iOS app. I just did it now.
8. tln ◴[] No.45065542{3}[source]
I get blue (on) / black (off) on the website. Or blue / white in light mode.

https://claude.ai/settings/data-privacy-controls

It was easy to not opt-in, I got prompted before I saw any of this.

I think they should keep the opt-in behavior past Sept 28 personally.

replies(1): >>45067375 #
9. gpm ◴[] No.45066715{4}[source]
This link is not even remotely close to an example of the behavior you described.
10. IAmGraydon ◴[] No.45067375{4}[source]
They’re likely A/B testing the interface change, which is why people are getting inconsistent results