←back to thread

416 points floverfelt | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.24s | source
Show context
nicwolff ◴[] No.45057148[source]
> I’ve often heard, with decent reason, an LLM compared to a junior colleague.

No, they're like an extremely experienced and knowledgeable senior colleague – who drinks heavily on the job. Overconfident, forgetful, sloppy, easily distracted. But you can hire so many of them, so cheaply, and they don't get mad when you fire them!

replies(11): >>45057296 #>>45057327 #>>45057402 #>>45058005 #>>45058021 #>>45058031 #>>45058066 #>>45058320 #>>45058354 #>>45059469 #>>45060122 #
vkou ◴[] No.45057296[source]
Experienced and knowledgeable and they also believe in the technical equivalent of flat-Earthism in many, many non-trivial corners.

And if you push back on that insanity, they'll smile and nod and agree with you and in the next sentence, go right back to pushing that nonsense.

replies(2): >>45057917 #>>45060158 #
DrewADesign ◴[] No.45060158[source]
“Here’s the code:” looks totally plausible but hallucinated libFakeCall.

“libFakeCall doesn’t exist. Use libRealCall instead of libFakeCall.”

“You’re absolutely correct. I apologize for blah blah blah blah. Here’s the updated code with libRealCall instead. :[…]”

“You just replaced the libFakeCall reference with libRealCall but didn’t update the calls themselves. Re-write it and cite the docs. “

“Sorry about the confusion! I’ve found these calls in the libRealCall docs. Here’s the new code and links to the docs.”

“That’s the same code but with links to the libRealCall docs landing page.”

“You’re absolutely correct.” It appears that these calls belong to another library with that functionality:” looks totally plausible but hallucinated libFakeCall.

replies(1): >>45060245 #
1. vkou ◴[] No.45060245[source]
You forgot to include it's best excuse for why the documentation it cites is hallucinated: "The links may be broken/website is down".

For all the hot air I hear about the user having to give the system the proper context to give you good answers - does anyone claim to have a solution for dealing with such a belligerent approach to bullshit?

They are by no means useless, but once they fall into that hole, there's no further value in interrogating them.