←back to thread

441 points longcat | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
f311a ◴[] No.45038992[source]
People really need to start thinking twice when adding a new dependency. So many supply chain attacks this year.

This week, I needed to add a progress bar with 8 stats counters to my Go project. I looked at the libraries, and they all had 3000+ lines of code. I asked LLM to write me a simple progress report tracking UI, and it was less than 150 lines. It works as expected, no dependencies needed. It's extremely simple, and everyone can understand the code. It just clears the terminal output and redraws it every second. It is also thread-safe. Took me 25 minutes to integrate it and review the code.

If you don't need a complex stats counter, a simple progress bar is like 30 lines of code as well.

This is a way to go for me now when considering another dependency. We don't have the resources to audit every package update.

replies(17): >>45039115 #>>45039225 #>>45039464 #>>45039724 #>>45039994 #>>45040021 #>>45040056 #>>45040113 #>>45040151 #>>45040162 #>>45040972 #>>45041479 #>>45041745 #>>45044165 #>>45045435 #>>45045983 #>>45052913 #
coldpie ◴[] No.45039464[source]
> People really need to start thinking twice when adding a new dependency. So many supply chain attacks this year.

I was really nervous when "language package managers" started to catch on. I work in the systems programming world, not the web world, so for the past decade, I looked from a distance at stuff like pip and npm and whatever with kind of a questionable side-eye. But when I did a Rust project and saw how trivially easy it was to pull in dozens of completely un-reviewed dependencies from the Internet with Cargo via a single line in a config file, I knew we were in for a bad time. Sure enough. This is a bad direction, and we need to turn back now. (We won't. There is no such thing as computer security.)

replies(12): >>45039683 #>>45039767 #>>45039803 #>>45039880 #>>45042370 #>>45043322 #>>45043362 #>>45045627 #>>45045717 #>>45046052 #>>45046055 #>>45046709 #
skydhash ◴[] No.45039803[source]
The thing is, system based package managers require discipline, especially from library authors. Even in the web world, it’s really distressing when you see a minor library is already on its 15 iteration in less that 5 years.

I was trying to build just (the task runner) on Debian 12 and it was impossible. It kept complaining about rust version, then some libraries shenanigans. It is way easier to build Emacs and ffmpeg.

replies(1): >>45041560 #
ajross ◴[] No.45041560{3}[source]
Indeed, it seems insane that we're pining for the days of autotools, configure scripts and the cleanly inspectable dependency structure.

But... We absolutely are.

replies(1): >>45048739 #
1. kalaksi ◴[] No.45048739{4}[source]
Disagree. And why wouldn't dep structure be cleanly inspectable.
replies(1): >>45064222 #
2. ajross ◴[] No.45064222[source]
Decades ago, you'd type "configure" and be told you need to install libfoobar version 9, and you would, and it would work.

Now you get npm whining at you about an unsatisfiable dependency cycle because some three-level-removed transitive dependency you've never heard of put a hard lock file in that reference a version that got pulled for a security flaw.