←back to thread

278 points Michelangelo11 | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
freefaler ◴[] No.45038516[source]
So as a pilot you can't override the software to stop it from "thinking that the plane is on the ground" mode?

Something similar happened recently with A320 when it didn't want to land on an airfield during emergency unless it was flown in a special mode. But F-35 doesn't have that?

replies(6): >>45038623 #>>45039289 #>>45039382 #>>45040610 #>>45041772 #>>45045256 #
netsharc ◴[] No.45039289[source]
> unless it was flown in a special mode.

What fresh hell is that... reboot, jam F8 just as the "Airbus" logo shows up, and then select "Boot in safe mode"?

replies(4): >>45039408 #>>45039526 #>>45040492 #>>45041141 #
1. xattt ◴[] No.45039408[source]
Fly-by-wire aircraft have changeable “flight laws” that correspond to different levels of computer intervention to mitigate situations incompatible with controlled flight.

Think of it as various stability control modes in a modern car. Likely the aircraft needed to be put in the least restrictive flight law mode as a workaround.

replies(1): >>45040078 #
2. lazide ◴[] No.45040078[source]
‘Incompatible with controlled flight’ is my new ‘rapid unscheduled disassembly’.

Notably, most drones have similar levels of control. Everything has to go through the IMU of course (nobody is manually going to be managing 4 separate motor controllers at once), but depending on the modes, the type of control is wildly different.

‘Consumer’/‘idiot’ mode - you tell it which direction to go, and how high/low you want it, and it’ll do that safely. Usually with some sort of object detection/avoidance, auto GPS input, so you won’t accidentally wander into something or hit something. Goal is stable, level flight.

‘Sport’ mode - go fast, usually disables all but the most simple collision avoidance. Sometimes even that. Still provides stable, level flight, but you can easily crash it. Usually goes 2-3x faster than ‘idiot’ mode.

‘Attitude’ or ‘acrobatic’ mode - you’re directly commanding the target 3D pitch/yaw, and aggregate power output. No provision is given to automatically maintaining level flight (won’t auto level), generally no regard is given to airframe integrity, collision avoidance, or engine life, and boy is it fun.

It’s really common to crash in this mode, because people are also doing flips, acrobatic maneuvers, running courses, etc.

Drones in even ‘sport’ mode can’t do flips because it’s fundamentally at odds with auto maintaining level flight, etc.