←back to thread

310 points speckx | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.234s | source
Show context
yodon ◴[] No.45038582[source]
More than anything, Microsoft is incompetent at messaging and communications.

This is a feature that has been among the most loved aspects of its main competitor for more than a decade.

Somehow, Microsoft managed to make the same feature sound and feel and be creepy.

replies(6): >>45038664 #>>45038672 #>>45038719 #>>45038787 #>>45039015 #>>45040697 #
1. clejack ◴[] No.45038719[source]
While incompetence might be an issue, I think the greater problem is that Microsoft is rolling back control and generally sucks at UX.

Why does this app that's been working just fine as desktop software need to save anything to the cloud by default? It's conceptually odd.

I've used Google docs from the beginning, but I actively choose what docs I want on that platform.

All MS had to do was add "save to cloud" as an additional save option along with "save" and "save as" (maybe renamed as "save to desktop") then auto save could activate where your last save location was. This would be good design.

replies(3): >>45039967 #>>45042348 #>>45044258 #
2. ◴[] No.45039967[source]
3. fragmede ◴[] No.45042348[source]
Who's incompetence? When half their users need to ask "what's a cloud", that option is too complicated. What's sensible and reasonable and logical to us, isn't to the rest of the world.
4. rekabis ◴[] No.45044258[source]
> Microsoft is rolling back control

Agreed. Functionality like this should be presented as a choice in an OOBE welcoming screen right after installation. And it should be _a choice,_ something that can be reversed at a later date if the decision was wrong.