←back to thread

Claude for Chrome

(www.anthropic.com)
795 points davidbarker | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.202s | source
Show context
aliljet ◴[] No.45030980[source]
Having played a LOT with browser use, playwright, and puppeteer (all via MCP integrations and pythonic test cases), it's incredibly clear how quickly Claude (in particular) loses the thread as it starts to interact with the browser. There's a TON of visual and contextual information that just vanishes as you begin to do anything particularly complex. In my experience, repeatedly forcing new context windows between screenshots has dramatically improved the ability for claude to perform complex intearctions in the browser, but it's all been pretty weak.

When Claude can operate in the browser and effectively understand 5 radio buttons in a row, I think we'll have made real progress. So far, I've not seen that eval.

replies(7): >>45031153 #>>45031164 #>>45031750 #>>45032251 #>>45033961 #>>45034552 #>>45036980 #
MattSayar ◴[] No.45031164[source]
Same. When I try to get it to do a simple loop (eg take screenshot, click next, repeat) it'll work for about five iterations (out of a hundred or so desired) then say, "All done, boss!"

I'm hoping Anthropic's browser extension is able to do some of the same "tricks" that Claude Code uses to gloss over these kinds of limitations.

replies(4): >>45031408 #>>45031587 #>>45031820 #>>45033874 #
1. robots0only ◴[] No.45031587[source]
Claude is extremely poor at vision when compared to Gemini and ChatGPT. i think anthropic severely overfit their evals to coding/text etc. use cases. maybe naively adding browser use would work, but I am a bit skeptical.
replies(2): >>45031690 #>>45032320 #
2. bdangubic ◴[] No.45031690[source]
I have a completely different experience. Pasting a screenshot into CC is my de-facto go-to that more often than not leads to CC understanding what needs to be done etc…
replies(1): >>45032230 #
3. ◴[] No.45032230[source]
4. user453 ◴[] No.45032320[source]
Is it overfitting if it makes them the best at those tasks?