←back to thread

360 points danielmorozoff | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
femiagbabiaka ◴[] No.45029594[source]
Have there been any reviews by independent experts? This reads like a promo piece, in particular I'm not sure why the fluff bits about Musk "being a regular guy" are relevant. Most of the linked sources are either other Fortune puff pieces or Neuralink press releases.
replies(6): >>45029687 #>>45029720 #>>45029783 #>>45029963 #>>45030098 #>>45030368 #
kevinpet ◴[] No.45029720[source]
Reviews by independent experts about the quality of this guy's life? I think he can be considered an authority on that subject.
replies(6): >>45029774 #>>45029797 #>>45029804 #>>45029912 #>>45029918 #>>45031497 #
micromacrofoot ◴[] No.45029797[source]
so are people who claim placebos and homeopathy improved their conditions, we are not reliable on an individual level
replies(3): >>45029836 #>>45029931 #>>45029978 #
db48x ◴[] No.45029931[source]
Placebos only effect subjective outcomes, not objective ones.
replies(1): >>45030256 #
nerevarthelame ◴[] No.45030256[source]
That's not categorically true. Although a placebo inherently relies on a patient's subjective understanding of receiving a treatment, that understanding can change any number of very objective outcomes. That's why so many studies that measure objective metrics use placebos to begin with.
replies(1): >>45030347 #
1. omarspira ◴[] No.45030347{3}[source]
a good point, and one that highlights the fact that people are unironically relying on "objective"/"subjective" distinctions in this thread - when this division is not necessarily a straightforward one in neurology or philosophy/language. putting a neurological implant in someone's brain doesn't strike me as an act that immediately clarifies this issue, to put it mildly. but this technology is still in its infancy. thus, the more people to "review" it, the better... doesn't mean the benefits they are giving people or the work has to stop... it just doesn't mean some skepticism isn't warranted either...