←back to thread

379 points impish9208 | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.021s | source | bottom
1. msgodel ◴[] No.45015906[source]
Just kill the phone. It's a terrible anachronism. If you insist on voice you can attach an ogg/mp3 file to your email.
replies(2): >>45016291 #>>45016735 #
2. nativeit ◴[] No.45016291[source]
I'm not one of the people down-voting this, I'm inclined to sort of agree with you. Where you lost me was attaching files to an email. Are you really suggesting this solution has fewer problems than telephones?
replies(2): >>45016581 #>>45016585 #
3. ratelimitsteve ◴[] No.45016581[source]
I'm here for the explanation as to how attached voice clips are equivalent to real time two-way voice communication
4. unsignedint ◴[] No.45016585[source]
Well, isn’t that essentially what voicemail is? We already have a mechanism to send voices as files—it’s just that not all voicemail systems deliver them in that format.

It wouldn’t solve everything, but considering how many scammers rely on real-time urgency in their calls, shifting phone communication toward asynchronous messages could actually help. It would undercut that pressure tactic, and it would also make record-keeping much easier.

5. Mashimo ◴[] No.45016735[source]
How I imagine you ~~calling~~ emailing the fire department: https://youtu.be/uesx85EHRTo (The IT crowd - Moss Contacts Fire Department)
replies(1): >>45017114 #
6. msgodel ◴[] No.45017114[source]
Sure, put the emergency hotline on the internet. It already is very special and doesn't use the phone network the way other voice calls do.
replies(1): >>45018635 #
7. unsignedint ◴[] No.45018635{3}[source]
Maybe shutting down the entire phone system would be too disruptive, but perhaps we could start by rethinking incoming calls for individuals—or at least shift the social norm around them. In a sense, that trend has already begun, since most people won’t pick up if the number is unfamiliar. And in circles where multi-modal communication is the default, how often do you actually get a legitimate call over PSTN anymore?

Legitimacy aside, the only people who still call me without prior arrangement tend to be those who assume they’re entitled to my time and attention on demand. The phone has always been a disruptive form of communication—even if every single call were legitimate (which is far from reality)—because it disregards the boundaries of the recipient’s time.

That’s why I stopped giving anyone real-time PSTN access. For me, it’s voicemail-only now, and honestly, it’s the best decision I’ve made for cutting down on annoyances.