←back to thread

469 points ghuntley | 9 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source | bottom
1. akk0 ◴[] No.45002466[source]
If a picture is usually worth 1000 words, the pictures in this are on a 99.6% discount. What the actual...?
replies(1): >>45002500 #
2. ghuntley ◴[] No.45002500[source]
It's a conference workshop; these are the slides from the workshop, and the words are a dictation from the delivery.
replies(1): >>45002594 #
3. akk0 ◴[] No.45002594[source]
That seems like a leaky implementation detail to me, for a published piece.
replies(2): >>45003491 #>>45020768 #
4. mg74 ◴[] No.45003491{3}[source]
You should learn to be grateful for what other people do on their own time and demand nothing from you for you to benefit from it.
replies(3): >>45003608 #>>45004294 #>>45004884 #
5. ghuntley ◴[] No.45003608{4}[source]
Thanks, mate.
6. crazygringo ◴[] No.45004294{4}[source]
On the other hand, when we critique, it is for the benefit of everyone who reads the critique and learns from it.

That's why critique has value. To the original author/artist (if they see it), but also to everyone else who sees it. "Oh, I was going to intersperse text slides with a transcript, but I remember how offputting that was once on HN, so let's skip the slides."

replies(1): >>45008705 #
7. aiaizbba ◴[] No.45004884{4}[source]
The article in question is written by a person who stands to benefit heavily from AI & agents succeeding. They appear to be a true believer so this isn’t a disparaging comment, but a snake oil salesman would display the same behavior.
8. jsnell ◴[] No.45008705{5}[source]
Text slides interspersed with the transcript work great normally.

But this is mostly slides with just four words of content, and a transcript that just be repeats the same words.

9. JamesSwift ◴[] No.45020768{3}[source]
I look forward to anything I see ghuntley post, and Ive gotten a lot of benefit from his contributions especially in the .net space, but I have to agree here. The format was distracting and really affected my ability to read it. I havent seen the live version, but I have a feeling the slide deck format would also be distracting (2-4 words per slide is really not communicating ideas effectively when you need all the words to form the sentence).