←back to thread

728 points freetonik | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
thallavajhula ◴[] No.44976973[source]
I’m loving today. HN’s front page is filled with some good sources today. No nonsense sensationalism or preaching AI doom, but more realistic experiences.

I’ve completely turned off AI assist on my personal computer and only use AI assist sparingly on my work computer. It is so bad at compound work. AI assist is great at atomic work. The rest should be handled by humans and use AI wisely. It all boils down back to human intelligence. AI is only as smart as the human handling it. That’s the bottom line.

replies(7): >>44977081 #>>44977158 #>>44977688 #>>44977874 #>>44977875 #>>44978045 #>>44985621 #
tick_tock_tick ◴[] No.44977158[source]
> AI is only as smart as the human handling it.

I think I'm slowly coming around to this viewpoint too. I really just couldn't understand how so many people were having widely different experiences. AI isn't magic; how could I have expected all the people I've worked with who struggle to explain stuff to team members, who have near perfect context, to manage to get anything valuable across to an AI?

I was original pretty optimistic that AI would allow most engineers to operate at a higher level but it really seems like instead it's going to massively exacerbate the difference between an ok engineer and a great engineer. Not really sure how I feel about that yet but at-least I understand now why some people think the stuff is useless.

replies(7): >>44977321 #>>44977339 #>>44977381 #>>44977394 #>>44977512 #>>44978132 #>>44982102 #
1. felipeerias ◴[] No.44982102[source]
At the moment, AI tools are particularly useful for people who feel comfortable browsing through large amounts of text, intuitively nudging the machine this way and that until arriving at a valuable outcome.

However, that way of working can be exasperating for those who prefer a more deterministic approach, and who may feel frustrated by the sheer amount of slightly incorrect stuff being generated by the machine.