←back to thread

495 points guntars | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
Seattle3503 ◴[] No.44981374[source]
> For example when submitting a write operation, the memory location of those bytes must not be deallocated or overwritten.

> The io-uring crate doesn’t help much with this. The API doesn’t allow the borrow checker to protect you at compile time, and I don’t see it doing any runtime checks either.

I've seen comments like this before[1], and I get the impression that building a a safe async Rust library around io_uring is actually quite difficult. Which is sort of a bummer.

IIRC Alice from the tokio team also suggested there hasn't been much interest in pushing through these difficulties more recently, as the current performance is "good enough".

[1] https://boats.gitlab.io/blog/post/io-uring/

replies(7): >>44981390 #>>44981469 #>>44981966 #>>44982846 #>>44983850 #>>44983930 #>>44989979 #
JoshTriplett ◴[] No.44981390[source]
I think the right way to build a safe interface around io_uring would be to use ring-owned buffers, ask the ring for a buffer when you want one, and give the buffer back to the ring when initiating a write.
replies(2): >>44981470 #>>44982162 #
1. pingiun ◴[] No.44981470[source]
This is something that Amos Wenger (fasterthanlime) has worked on: https://github.com/bearcove/loona/blob/main/crates/buffet/RE...