←back to thread

1163 points DaveZale | 10 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source | bottom
Show context
tlogan ◴[] No.44771408[source]
Maybe Helsinki isn’t special: just fewer cars. And they apparently only 21% of daily trips used a private car.

Helsinki has about 3x fewer vehicles per capita than the average U.S. city. So it’s not surprising it’s safer since fewer cars mean fewer chances of getting hit by one. Plus their cars are much smaller.

In fact, there are probably plenty of U.S. towns and cities with similar number of cars that have zero traffic deaths (quick search says that Jersey City, New Jersey has zero traffic deaths in 2022).

So maybe it’s not about urban planning genius or Scandinavian magic. Maybe it’s just: fewer things that can kill you on the road.

I wonder how the numbers will change when majority of cars are autonomous.

replies(12): >>44771469 #>>44771494 #>>44771498 #>>44772194 #>>44773223 #>>44773250 #>>44774089 #>>44774580 #>>44774620 #>>44774831 #>>44775458 #>>44779603 #
1. rimbo789 ◴[] No.44771469[source]
Itll for sure get worse once most cars are autonomous and are programmed badly
replies(1): >>44771731 #
2. egypturnash ◴[] No.44771731[source]
Every time I see a Cybertruck while I'm on my bike I am stunned at how badly that thing is designed, it's got a hood higher than my head and a front that slopes backwards as it goes down, so that anything it hits is just naturally shoved under it, this is a machine built for vehicular homicide. How the fuck did that get allowed on the road at all.
replies(2): >>44771832 #>>44771978 #
3. levocardia ◴[] No.44771832[source]
FWIW Cybertruck (and all other teslas) have a forward collision warning system that can detect pedestrians and automatically brake. Not perfectly of course, but better than other cars. Large cars are not the primary driver of increased pedestrian deaths in the USA, either.
replies(3): >>44772098 #>>44772767 #>>44773994 #
4. globalise83 ◴[] No.44771978[source]
It's not allowed in Europe, and I very much doubt it ever will be.
5. derektank ◴[] No.44772098{3}[source]
>Large cars are not the primary driver of increased pedestrian deaths in the USA, either.

What is the primary cause of increased US pedestrian deaths?

replies(1): >>44773639 #
6. jamesblonde ◴[] No.44772767{3}[source]
"Large cars are not the primary driver of increased pedestrian deaths in the USA"

Evidence free claim. Sometimes correlation indicates causation.

replies(1): >>44776409 #
7. sosborn ◴[] No.44773639{4}[source]
My money would go on mobile phone usage.
replies(1): >>44776539 #
8. wyre ◴[] No.44773994{3}[source]
Incorrect. Light trucks account for 54% of pedestrian fatalities compared to passenger cars at 37%. Impossible for more than half to not be considered the primary cause.

https://www.ghsa.org/resource-hub/pedestrian-traffic-fatalit...

9. ◴[] No.44776409{4}[source]
10. jeromegv ◴[] No.44776539{5}[source]
Every countries in the world got cellphones. Many saw a drop in fatalies on the road, others it went up (US). Cellphones surely don’t help and are awful but once you hit someone the size of the car (and speed!) matters on the outcome and cars are bigger in the US.