←back to thread

280 points dargscisyhp | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
m101 ◴[] No.44765789[source]
UCLA has an endowment of 3.8bn$. Whilst I'm sympathetic to their desire to be further government financed for the work they do, I feel like government financing should be made available to those that actually need the money. The attitude that you have access to government funds even if you have the ability to pay yourself needs to change.
replies(8): >>44765839 #>>44765844 #>>44765941 #>>44765982 #>>44766058 #>>44766567 #>>44766832 #>>44768509 #
noelwelsh ◴[] No.44765982[source]
Governments typically fund research because 1) it's seen as beneficial for the country, and hence falls under the remit of governments in democratic countries and 2) the uncertainty, time frame, or lack of direct commercialization of research typically means the private sector will not invest in it.

Your suggestion is saying that research should be privatised, and shows very little thought about how research works and who benefits from it.

replies(3): >>44766035 #>>44766444 #>>44766753 #
m101 ◴[] No.44766753[source]
You make this statement as if it's fact. The actual reality of the matter is that neither you nor I know how research would progress were the government not stepping in and spending on our behalf. Your kind of argument is what is used to justify increasing amounts of government taxation and spending, over trusting the private sector to figure out ways of doing so, and the suggestion that government is the only way of incentivising the research you speak of is entirely lacking in imagination and faith in basic human ingenuity to solve problems.

Yes, there are coordination problems for projects at some scale, for which government involvement makes it possible, however these are far fewer than we are made to believe.

replies(1): >>44767773 #
1. whamlastxmas ◴[] No.44767773[source]
There are tons of labs at universities that are privately funded. It’s not common but there’s plenty of them. And the one I know best is probably the top in the world for what it does (niche in physics)