←back to thread

290 points XzetaU8 | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.477s | source
Show context
blindriver ◴[] No.44658043[source]
This is why I’m not moving off Windows 10. I’d rather move to MacOS than Windows 11 and if they force me I’ll do it.
replies(3): >>44658051 #>>44659248 #>>44663177 #
deadbabe ◴[] No.44658051[source]
Why not Linux?
replies(3): >>44658087 #>>44658504 #>>44659691 #
ubermonkey ◴[] No.44658087[source]
I'm not who you asked, but the reason I migrated to Macs years ago, and the reason I stay, is that I don't want my computer to be a maintenance hobby unto itself. I need to do actual work.

I also enjoy the polish Apple provides in other ways -- the platform features you get if you're on a Mac, use an iPhone, have a Watch, etc, are all pretty great. Cobbling together something like that on my own under Linux probably isn't possible.

replies(5): >>44658125 #>>44658153 #>>44658157 #>>44658180 #>>44658406 #
dspillett ◴[] No.44658406[source]
> I don't want my computer to be a maintenance hobby unto itself

That hasn't been the case with Linux, any more than other OSs, for some time now. At least not if you chose an LTS release of a big “getting work done” oriented distro rather than something geared around the bleeding edge or customisability.

There are issues with some software support, but that is almost all Windows stuff that you'll have the same problems with on Macs as Linux.

There are occasional hardware issues, which is where Apple limiting choice in favour of known reliability can look attractive, but that is mostly on the bleeding edge too which isn't a concern if you are “getting work done” (I had issues with some 2.5GbE NICs a while ago and swapped them back out, retried with the same kit last month, at least on apt-release-update later, and things are working just fine).

> if you're on a Mac, use an iPhone, have a Watch, etc,

I can see that.

Though I prefer to select my devices based on what they are best at rather than being locked to a single manufacturer's ecosystem. My watch (Garmin) and phone (Android) talk to each other just fine and integration with the desktop when I need it (mostly for planning routes & pacing plans using maps on the big screen) is web-based so works just as well with Linux as Widows or Macs.

replies(1): >>44658897 #
1. mattmanser ◴[] No.44658897[source]
Scan your comment:

That hasn't been the case with Linux...for some time now

There are issues

There are occasional hardware issue

You're arguing against yourself.

replies(2): >>44659153 #>>44659802 #
2. teddyh ◴[] No.44659153[source]
Windows has plenty of issues and hardware problems! It’s just that nobody ever blames Windows for them. It works like this:

Headset does not work on Linux: “This is crap, I’ll tell everybody I know to stay away from Linux!”

Headset does not work on Windows: “This is crap, I’ll tell everybody I know to stay away from these headphones!”

(Re-post from 2022: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32541772>)

3. dspillett ◴[] No.44659802[source]
Admitting that it isn't perfect is called being adult and offering a realistic assessment. I've had more issues with hardware with Windows in the past than Linux. Under the Apple system hardware issues are “solved” by simply limiting what is considered compatible.

Maybe actually read the my comment, in which I mention such caveats, instead of just scanning to pluck out the few words which agree with your existing blinkered view. Your reply is like film posters paraphrasing quotes like “Terribly written, nothing good to say about it!” to “Terribly good!”…