←back to thread

243 points greesil | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
apples_oranges ◴[] No.44636362[source]
Looking at the picture, I wonder if complexity of these devices will significantly be reduced once it finally works. I assume a lot of the bells and whistles are needed to find the way, but once it's found..
replies(5): >>44636480 #>>44637039 #>>44637055 #>>44637482 #>>44637537 #
StevenWaterman ◴[] No.44636480[source]
Your question reminds me of the image showing how SpaceX raptor motors evolved https://imgur.com/a/4w3q3lS
replies(5): >>44636512 #>>44637280 #>>44637705 #>>44640370 #>>44642797 #
GMoromisato ◴[] No.44642797[source]
To be fair, the reason the right-most Raptor looks so clean is because they moved all the piping (all the complexity) to inside the casing. And the reason they made the effort is because the casing protects the tubing from the heat of re-entry. Otherwise they'd have to waste mass on heat shielding. [Take a look at videos of Superheavy Booster returning back to the launch tower--the bottom engine sections starts to glow from the heat.]

I don't think that applies to Stellarators, so there may not be an incentive to simplify it. [But what do I know; I'm just a simple programmer.]

replies(1): >>44643890 #
1. lux44 ◴[] No.44643890[source]
> the bottom engine sections starts to glow from the heat

It's fuel burning, not glow. Speed is too low for glowing; glow would start at the edge, not from deep inside the skirt etc.