←back to thread

243 points greesil | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.205s | source
Show context
apples_oranges ◴[] No.44636362[source]
Looking at the picture, I wonder if complexity of these devices will significantly be reduced once it finally works. I assume a lot of the bells and whistles are needed to find the way, but once it's found..
replies(5): >>44636480 #>>44637039 #>>44637055 #>>44637482 #>>44637537 #
StevenWaterman ◴[] No.44636480[source]
Your question reminds me of the image showing how SpaceX raptor motors evolved https://imgur.com/a/4w3q3lS
replies(5): >>44636512 #>>44637280 #>>44637705 #>>44640370 #>>44642797 #
ortusdux ◴[] No.44636512[source]
I'm not keen on the idea of applying a 'keep subtracting things until it blows up' mentality to fusion reactors.
replies(7): >>44636564 #>>44636626 #>>44636689 #>>44636700 #>>44636961 #>>44637552 #>>44637660 #
xorxornop ◴[] No.44636626[source]
I wouldn't be concerned about this, personally, for the precise reason that it is a fusion device - not fission!

Fusion is incredibly difficult just to start, let alone keep burning - unlike fission, which is only too happy to enter runaway conditions if not very carefully regulated. Fusion is like a little ember in your fireplace you have to carefully blow on to keep alight; fission is like keeping a fireplace lit by pouring gasoline into it.

replies(1): >>44636867 #
grues-dinner ◴[] No.44636867[source]
I'd say (older-generation) fission is more like having an indoor swimming pool filled with burning gasoline, but keeping the windows shut so there's only enough air for it to burn at the rate you want to heat the house.
replies(1): >>44637190 #
HPsquared ◴[] No.44637190[source]
Or a swimming pool full of those spicy rocket propellents discussed in the book Ignition! which have combustion products like hydrogen fluoride.
replies(3): >>44637690 #>>44637727 #>>44637939 #
sheepscreek ◴[] No.44637727[source]
Would love to take a look at your library.
replies(1): >>44641094 #
1. FiatLuxDave ◴[] No.44641094[source]
Not the poster above, but as someone who also has a copy of Ignition! in their library, I think you might enjoy the pdf version:

https://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/ignition.pd...