←back to thread

LLM Inevitabilism

(tomrenner.com)
1613 points SwoopsFromAbove | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.291s | source
Show context
lsy ◴[] No.44568114[source]
I think two things can be true simultaneously:

1. LLMs are a new technology and it's hard to put the genie back in the bottle with that. It's difficult to imagine a future where they don't continue to exist in some form, with all the timesaving benefits and social issues that come with them.

2. Almost three years in, companies investing in LLMs have not yet discovered a business model that justifies the massive expenditure of training and hosting them, the majority of consumer usage is at the free tier, the industry is seeing the first signs of pulling back investments, and model capabilities are plateauing at a level where most people agree that the output is trite and unpleasant to consume.

There are many technologies that have seemed inevitable and seen retreats under the lack of commensurate business return (the supersonic jetliner), and several that seemed poised to displace both old tech and labor but have settled into specific use cases (the microwave oven). Given the lack of a sufficiently profitable business model, it feels as likely as not that LLMs settle somewhere a little less remarkable, and hopefully less annoying, than today's almost universally disliked attempts to cram it everywhere.

replies(26): >>44568145 #>>44568416 #>>44568799 #>>44569151 #>>44569734 #>>44570520 #>>44570663 #>>44570711 #>>44570870 #>>44571050 #>>44571189 #>>44571513 #>>44571570 #>>44572142 #>>44572326 #>>44572360 #>>44572627 #>>44572898 #>>44573137 #>>44573370 #>>44573406 #>>44574774 #>>44575820 #>>44577486 #>>44577751 #>>44577911 #
alonsonic ◴[] No.44570711[source]
I'm confused with your second point. LLM companies are not making any money from current models? Openai generates 10b USD ARR and has 100M MAUs. Yes they are running at a loss right now but that's because they are racing to improve models. If they stopped today to focus on optimization of their current models to minimize operating cost and monetizing their massive user base you think they don't have a successful business model? People use this tools daily, this is inevitable.
replies(11): >>44570725 #>>44570756 #>>44570760 #>>44570772 #>>44570780 #>>44570853 #>>44570896 #>>44570964 #>>44571007 #>>44571541 #>>44571655 #
ehutch79 ◴[] No.44571007[source]
Revenue is _NOT_ Profit
replies(2): >>44571163 #>>44571412 #
1. vuggamie ◴[] No.44571412[source]
It's a good point. Any business can get revenue by selling Twenty dollar bills for $19. But in the history of tech, many winners have been dismissed for lack of an apparent business model. Amazon went years losing money, and when the business stabilized, went years re-investing and never showed a profit. Analysts complained as Amazon expanded into non-retail activities. And then there's Uber.

The money is there. Investors believe this is the next big thing, and is a once in a lifetime opportunity. Bigger than the social media boom which made a bunch of billionaires, bigger than the dot com boom, bigger maybe than the invention of the microchip itself.

It's going to be years before any of these companies care about profit. Ad revenue is unlikely to fund the engineering and research they need. So the only question is, does the investor money dry up? I don't think so. Investor money will be chasing AGI until we get it or there's another AI winter.