←back to thread

360 points Eduard | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.433s | source
Show context
perdomon ◴[] No.44564794[source]
What happens when black holes collide? Does one black hole “consume” the other? Do they become a larger black hole? Does it get more dense or just larger?
replies(5): >>44564839 #>>44564889 #>>44564894 #>>44564906 #>>44565864 #
__MatrixMan__ ◴[] No.44564894[source]
They become a more massive one. The volume of a black hole (assuming you're measuring at the event horizon) is determined only by its mass, so the final density is the same as you'd get for any other black hole of that mass regardless of how it came to be.

I don't know how to address the "consume" question. If you were pulling on a piece of fabric and two tears in it grew until they met each other to become one tear... would you say that the larger one consumed the smaller?

replies(4): >>44565108 #>>44565339 #>>44565509 #>>44578126 #
dataflow ◴[] No.44565339[source]
> The volume of a black hole (assuming you're measuring at the event horizon) is determined only by its mass, so the final density is the same as you'd get for any other black hole of that mass regardless of how it came to be.

Wait, really? So if you had a super massive disk that was just 1 electron away from having enough mass to become a black hole... and then an electron popped into existence due to quantum randomness... then it would become a sphere instantly? Wouldn't that violate the speed of light or something?

replies(5): >>44565623 #>>44565670 #>>44565898 #>>44567103 #>>44567713 #
1. addaon ◴[] No.44565670[source]
> then it would become a sphere instantly

Event horizons are non-physical. Better to think of it as "then a spherical event horizon would become apparent." When the mass within a given black-hole-shaped volume (spherical for non-rotating mass) is "one electron short" of being a black hole, then one can define a surface in the shape of the (future) black hole where the escape velocity is /just/ below the speed of light. In practice, all light emitted within that volume will already be captured by the mass, unless it's perfectly perpendicular to the (future) event horizon. When that extra electron is added, it becomes true that the escape velocity at that same surface is now the speed of light -- the definition of event horizon. But nothing needs to "form" to make this true.