←back to thread

Kiro: A new agentic IDE

(kiro.dev)
1015 points QuinnyPig | 1 comments | 14 Jul 25 14:24 UTC | HN request time: 0.24s | source
Show context
suralind ◴[14 Jul 25 15:39 UTC] No.44561441[source]▶
Here my problem with this: I don't want to be jumping an editor/IDE every 6 months, learning new key bindings and even more importantly, getting used to a completely new look.

In a space that moves as quickly as "AI" does, it is inevitable that a better and cheaper solution will pop up at some point. We kinda already see it with Cursor and Windsurf. I guess Claude Code is all the rage now and I personally think CLI/TUI is the way to go for anyone that has a similar view.

That said, I'm sure there's a very big user base (probably bigger than terminal group) that will enjoy using this and other GUI apps.

replies(17): >>44561462 #>>44561479 #>>44561494 #>>44561503 #>>44561512 #>>44561592 #>>44561678 #>>44561889 #>>44562034 #>>44562091 #>>44563075 #>>44563576 #>>44564212 #>>44566667 #>>44569070 #>>44569580 #>>44569595 #
TimMeade ◴[14 Jul 25 15:43 UTC] No.44561503[source]▶
Every 6 months? It's turning into every two weeks. Sticking with claude code. Its working beautifully for us.
replies(2): >>44561522 #>>44561949 #
MuffinFlavored ◴[14 Jul 25 15:45 UTC] No.44561522[source]▶
I have a question. I do not like the concept of "agent mode" for AI. I'm a control freak and I want to control every line that gets committed because I am responsible for it and need to understand/visualize/memorize every part of codebases I work on.

Is Claude Code good for the "ask" flow? No, right?

The old flow before agent mode got added. Select some code, ask questions about it or give an instruction on editing it and then choose to accept the change.

As I understand (I could be wrong), with agent mode, it edits the file for you, no way for you to accept before it does, so you have to manually check the diff, roll back parts you don't want, etc.

Am I right?

replies(6): >>44561579 #>>44561587 #>>44561648 #>>44561661 #>>44561726 #>>44563237 #
1. dangus ◴[14 Jul 25 15:56 UTC] No.44561661[source]▶
> As I understand (I could be wrong), with agent mode, it edits the file for you, no way for you to accept before it does, so you have to manually check the diff, roll back parts you don't want, etc.

You’re sort of technically correct but I wouldn’t really describe it this way exactly. You have to proactively accept or reject all changes to your files in some way.

It is almost impossible to accidentally commit code you don’t want.

It’s not really an edit in the same sense as an unstated change. It doesn’t even really do that until you accept the result.

It’s basically saving you a UI step compared to ask mode with basically no downside.