←back to thread

314 points cjr | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.301s | source
Show context
maxbond ◴[] No.44539269[source]
I just want to call out that, whatever the facts of this case, pilot heroism is way more common than pilot murder. This is off the top of my head, so don't quote me on the precise details, I'm probably misremembering some things. But a few of my favorite examples:

- British Airways 5390: An incorrect repair causes the windshield of a plane to be blown out mid flight. A pilot is nearly sucked out. The head flight attendant holds onto his legs to keep him in the plane. The copilot and flight attendant think he is dead, but they keep the situation under control and land the plane.

Everyone survives - including the pilot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGwHWNFdOvg

- United 232: An engine explodes in the tail of an MD-10. Due to rotten luck and weaknesses in the design, it takes out all three of the redundant hydraulic systems, rendering the control surfaces inoperable.

There's a pilot onboard as a passenger who, it just so happens, has read about similar incidents in other aircraft and trained for this scenario on his own initiative. He joins the other pilots in the cockpit and they figure out how to use the engines to establish rudimentary control.

They crash just short of the runway. 112 people die, but 184 people survive.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pT7CgWvD-x4

- Pinnacle 3701: Two pilots mess around with an empty plane. They take it up to it's operational ceiling. While they're goofing off, they don't realize they're losing momentum. They try to correct too late and cannot land safely.

In their last moments they decide to sacrifice any chance they have to survive by not deploying their landing gear. They choose to glide for the maximum distance to avoid hitting houses, rather than maximizing how much impact is absorbed. They do hit a house but no one else is killed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCMmCekKO_c

replies(5): >>44539319 #>>44539704 #>>44540202 #>>44540842 #>>44540976 #
notpushkin ◴[] No.44539319[source]
Mentour Pilot is a fantastic channel.
replies(3): >>44539330 #>>44540021 #>>44542145 #
maxbond ◴[] No.44539330[source]
Anyone who does on-call should look into aviation disasters. Crew resource management, the aviate-navigate-communicate loop, it's all very applicable. ('WalterBright is an excellent source of commentary on applying lessons from the airline industry to software.)

But I did burn out on Mentour Pilot after a while, I just had my fill of tragedy.

replies(3): >>44539928 #>>44540239 #>>44540419 #
1. padjo ◴[] No.44539928[source]
Something I love about Mentour pilot is that he’s started doing videos on incidents where there was a near miss but no tragedy. Just as much to learn but without the ghoulish rubbernecking aspect.