←back to thread

Apple vs the Law

(formularsumo.co.uk)
378 points tempodox | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.425s | source
Show context
grishka ◴[] No.44529279[source]
> "...unfortunately, it's impossible to do all the complex engineering to comply with the Commission's current interpretation of the DMA..."

There's nothing complex and impossible about removing some "if" statements responsible for code signature enforcement.

replies(9): >>44529310 #>>44529322 #>>44529363 #>>44529431 #>>44529446 #>>44529695 #>>44530078 #>>44531016 #>>44531269 #
interpol_p ◴[] No.44529363[source]
It’s extremely complex. I’m not debating whether they should comply - they should. But it’s gonna cost them years of engineering effort, and maintenance far into the future. See, for example, BrowserEngineKit

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/browserenginekit

They needed to engineer, maintain, document and support a whole class of APIs so that third parties can create their own competitive browser engines (that offer JIT, etc) while still maintaining iOS sandbox security. There are going to be hundreds of frameworks, thousands of APIs, that will need to come to ensure compliance with the DMA

replies(2): >>44529396 #>>44529401 #
idle_zealot ◴[] No.44529396[source]
Or, they could just let their pocket computers run the software users download and install, like every single other computer ever made and sold, rather than special-case engineer padded cells for every use-case, application class, or bit of interoperability.
replies(3): >>44530059 #>>44530285 #>>44533417 #
itopaloglu83 ◴[] No.44530285[source]
An iPhone isn’t a pocket computer. It needs to be really secure because someone gaining full access to it through a badly written browser would cost you your life savings if not your life for some.
replies(2): >>44530328 #>>44537911 #
msgodel ◴[] No.44537911[source]
This is the case with any kind of computer and the iPhone is not particularly secure, you're just locked out of yours.
replies(1): >>44539104 #
1. itopaloglu83 ◴[] No.44539104[source]
Well, if I have a state actor after me then I have bigger problems already.

Security is relative concept. For most people being able to browse internet, add/remove apps, and be sure that they will not break things goes a long way.