←back to thread

299 points cjr | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
comrade1234 ◴[] No.44537976[source]
Why can the pilot shut off the fuel during takeoff?
replies(5): >>44538051 #>>44538072 #>>44538078 #>>44538334 #>>44539761 #
jeffbee ◴[] No.44538051[source]
Suggest a system that would prevent this, but only this, without causing other risks.
replies(3): >>44538226 #>>44538263 #>>44539579 #
1. bob1029 ◴[] No.44538263[source]
Disable the fuel system cutoff controls during the takeoff climb phase of flight. Once the aircraft loses contact with the runway, these controls shouldn't function without tripping certain thresholds (speed & altitude), or following a two-man procedure that is physically impossible to execute solo. In any other flight regime, the controls function as originally designed.

The danger of a burning engine is irrelevant if you are heading into terrain.

replies(3): >>44538396 #>>44538408 #>>44539894 #
2. dboreham ◴[] No.44538396[source]
Sounds good, but I'm not sure I trust Boeing outsourced software developers to implement that absolutely correctly.
3. yongjik ◴[] No.44538408[source]
Now you created a fuel system cutoff control inhibition system which may malfunction in its own ways, e.g., refuse to cut off fuels from a burning engine because it thinks the plane is too low due to faulty altimeter reading.
4. ExoticPearTree ◴[] No.44539894[source]
> The danger of a burning engine is irrelevant if you are heading into terrain.

Not quite. When you hit the ground you do not want any fuel leaks or hot surfaces as much as possible. That is why for example engines are shutdown when doing an emergency belly landing, to try abd prevent the airplane from bursting into flames.