←back to thread

688 points dheerajvs | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.473s | source
Show context
pera ◴[] No.44524261[source]
Wow these are extremely interesting results, specially this part:

> This gap between perception and reality is striking: developers expected AI to speed them up by 24%, and even after experiencing the slowdown, they still believed AI had sped them up by 20%.

I wonder what could explain such large difference between estimation/experience vs reality, any ideas?

Maybe our brains are measuring mental effort and distorting our experience of time?

replies(7): >>44524872 #>>44524974 #>>44525239 #>>44525349 #>>44528508 #>>44528626 #>>44530564 #
evanelias ◴[] No.44525349[source]
Here's a scary thought, which I'm admittedly basing on absolutely nothing scientific:

What if agentic coding sessions are triggering a similar dopamine feedback loop as social media apps? Obviously not to the same degree as social media apps, I mean coding for work is still "work"... but there's maybe some similarity in getting iterative solutions from the agent, triggering something in your brain each time, yes?

If that was the case, wouldn't we expect developers to have an overly positive perception of AI because they're literally becoming addicted to it?

replies(5): >>44525418 #>>44525471 #>>44526779 #>>44528433 #>>44532628 #
1. csherratt ◴[] No.44525471[source]
That's my suspicion to.

My issue with this being a 'negative' thing is that I'm not sure it is. It works off of the same hunting / foraging instincts that keep us alive. If you feel addiction to something positive, it is bad?

Social media is negative because it addicts you to mostly low quality filler content. Content that doesn't challenge you. You are reading shit posts instead of reading a book or doing something with better for you in the long run.

One could argue that's true for AI, but I'm not confident enough to make such a statement.

replies(1): >>44525552 #
2. evanelias ◴[] No.44525552[source]
The study found AI caused a "significant slowdown" in developer efficiency though, so that doesn't seem positive!