Most active commenters
  • mc32(3)

←back to thread

257 points toomuchtodo | 21 comments | | HN request time: 0.452s | source | bottom
Show context
isodev ◴[] No.44505504[source]
Nice. It’s amazing to see the progress Bulgarians have made in the last 20 years after joining the EU. I can imagine it hasn’t been an easy process.
replies(3): >>44505750 #>>44506369 #>>44507207 #
petesergeant ◴[] No.44505750[source]
Two things that surprised me when I spent a couple of months in Bulgaria:

* Bulgarian support for the EU is pretty low and people didn't think it made their life much better

* Bulgarian support for Russia is very high, like 50%, probably due to their historic help in kicking out the Turks

replies(5): >>44505782 #>>44506377 #>>44506656 #>>44506780 #>>44507322 #
1. mc32 ◴[] No.44505782[source]
Also the experience of Greece not too far back and the austerity imposed by Germany is not quite forgotten. Varoufakis[1] can attest to its severity. The Greeks voted against it but Germany imposed its will.

[1]https://jacobin.com/2025/07/yanis-varoufakis-on-the-legacy-o...

replies(4): >>44505805 #>>44505930 #>>44506107 #>>44506132 #
2. isodev ◴[] No.44505805[source]
And yet, Greece recovered to become a leading economy in the region. The propaganda is strong on the airwaves these days, just like in the US, one shouldn’t react to “facts” taken out of context.

It seems (from here), support for Russia is somehow magically going down as Russia’s economy is having trouble paying for its “support” abroad.

replies(4): >>44505838 #>>44505839 #>>44506969 #>>44508082 #
3. jazzyjackson ◴[] No.44505838[source]
In which region is Greece a leading economy?
replies(1): >>44505996 #
4. petesergeant ◴[] No.44505839[source]
> And yet, Greece recovered to become a leading economy in the region

I don't think that's true ... growth is good, but that's because there's a lot of catching up to do. If I remember correctly (and maybe I don't) then real GDP is still like -20% vs 2007, debt is EU-leading at like 150% of GDP, unemployment remains high, and wages remain low.

5. gbil ◴[] No.44505930[source]
This is a very distant view for the reasons behind the crisis in Greece and for sure the government of 2015 was not a victim. In the context of this thread, Bulgarians as Greeks before them, enjoy the money from the EU but don’t like the responsibility that comes from it, to reform, to also contribute and that you lose the own currency perks while you gain on other fronts. Of course there is a lot more here to discuss but this is my experience being a Greek in Greece.
replies(2): >>44506607 #>>44507135 #
6. dr_kretyn ◴[] No.44505996{3}[source]
In a region composed of Greece, North Macedonia and Cyprus.
replies(1): >>44506218 #
7. spookie ◴[] No.44506107[source]
You know, there's Greece and Portugal. Mentioning these two as they got Troika following them.

Portugal managed to get out of the storm, and debt is now below GDP.

Greece took many bad steps trying to recover. And its debt shows that. Their governments have had a big part of the blame. Hell, at one point they didnt have enough money for citizens to withdraw from banks.

And that was before Troika.

replies(1): >>44506406 #
8. dkjaudyeqooe ◴[] No.44506132[source]
This is nonsense. Not mentioned is that Greece has borrowed excessively and had defaulted on its loans. A bailout was organized by the EU and IMF with terms that Greece had every opportunity to reject. No one forced anything on Greece. The referendum was not binding and political theater for the government of the time.

That Greece accepted the terms reflected the reality that the alternative was much worse and would have caused great suffering for Greeks.

replies(2): >>44506290 #>>44506360 #
9. kyriakos ◴[] No.44506218{4}[source]
Doesn't sound right https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_in_...

Cyprus ranks 17th and Greece 32nd

10. ingohelpinger ◴[] No.44506290[source]
100% true.
11. mc32 ◴[] No.44506360[source]
What choice did Greece have? Germany was not extending favorable terms, they were punitive, so what choice did they have but take the least awful choice? Syriza tried but Germany had the upper hand and of course didn't give an inch --though Syriza tried very hard.

Varoufakis would argue the severe terms imposed by the creditors/negotiators exacerbated the fiscal issue. Yes Greece had issues but the creditors's terms exacerbated the problem, made things worse.

It's kind of like borrowing from a loan shark to pay off debts --on average, you're better off not. But hey, once you take it, you either pay up, or you lose something dear to you.

replies(2): >>44507194 #>>44507257 #
12. Ygg2 ◴[] No.44506406[source]
> And its debt shows that. Their governments have had a big part of the blame. Hell, at one point they didnt have enough money for citizens to withdraw from banks.

Sure but so do the creditors. If you keep giving mortgages to anyone with a drivers license that's on you buddy.

At almost no point is there enough money for citizens to withdraw their money. Modern banks don't keep their assets as cash.

replies(1): >>44506951 #
13. W3zzy ◴[] No.44506607[source]
The government was not the victim in deed. But up until today you can see the results amongst the population. You can Prune for growt or you can just cut the plant to the ground hoping it will survive.
14. guappa ◴[] No.44506951{3}[source]
> If you keep giving mortgages to anyone with a drivers license that's on you buddy.

Isn't this the USA system?

replies(1): >>44507598 #
15. shakow ◴[] No.44506969[source]
> to become a leading economy in the region.

Leading compared to what, Romania and North Macedonia?

> support for Russia is somehow magically going down

I don't think support for Russia was ever notably involved in the whole clusterfuck regarding the Greek economy.

16. omnimus ◴[] No.44507135[source]
Greece was sacrificed so eurozone (especialy Germany) could hide recession by bailing out banks (through bailing out Hreece). Greeks know and believe this. That makes their relationship with EU quite complicated.
17. omnimus ◴[] No.44507194{3}[source]
It was disqusting treatment from EU which needed to hide its own recession and blame a culprit.

Every other european media outlet talked about greeks (in very racist way) as lazy nation that doesnt want to work.

Not great look for EU. But i dont know about better alternative.

18. dmos62 ◴[] No.44507257{3}[source]
Greece underreported its debt until 2009: i.e. it borrowed too much while lying about how much it's already borrowed. That's the main difference between Greece on the one hand and Italy, Portugal on the other, in my eyes. Italy and Portugal too suffered a public debt crises, but they weren't so blatant about it. I sympathize with the common Greek man, and I wish their crises had been managed with more success, but I also don't feel especially interested in bankrolling Greek policies that led to this crises.
replies(1): >>44509587 #
19. Ygg2 ◴[] No.44507598{4}[source]
Not just the USA system. EU and especially German banks gave plenty of credits to Greek banks, knowing that they will probably spend it on German products, even if they have not much means to repay them. Plus, the EU knows full well that if Greeks overspend they can easily be pressured into austerity.

This went swimmingly for everyone involved, with Greece now in more debt than ever (debt went from 145.45% of GDP to 209.40% of GDP). And fascist parties going from virtually non-existent to mainstays.

Adding low-efficiency countries like those in southeastern Europe is great for the EU's major exporter - Germany, because it adds more customers who have Euros, and because it devalues the Euro, which means more exports. Better yet, because of Euro the new joiners can't devalue their currency and get their exports high enough to restart the economy, with only viable option being more in debt and/or leaving for Germany, while obliterating the local industries. Win-win-win. For the EU exporters.

So, yes, let's celebrate Bulgaria joining Hotel EU, where food is great, your bill grows exponentially, but you can't ever leave. By the end you'll just end up as a pool boy.

20. xdennis ◴[] No.44508082[source]
I'm not quite sure about that. Romania is bigger because it has a bigger population, but look even at this GDP per capita comparison with Romania.

    Greece: 31695 (2008), 25756 (2025), 31014 (2030, projected)
   Romania: 10435 (2008), 21421 (2025), 28809 (2030, projected)
It won't be until 2030 that Greece will recover, and I'm pretty sure it's slow growth is because of its huge debt because of the euro.
21. mc32 ◴[] No.44509587{4}[source]
I dunno. Pretty sure creditors aren't innocent little old ladies. They're financial killers and knew the situation but also knew they had Germany and the Troika behind them to save them if things went south (as they did). It was win-win for them. The economy miraculously grows: win! the economy sours: win!