←back to thread

Are we the baddies?

(geohot.github.io)
693 points AndrewSwift | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.346s | source
Show context
hardwaresofton ◴[] No.44478703[source]
> If you open a government S&P 500 account for everyone with $1,000 at birth that’ll pay their social security cause it like…goes up…wait who’s creating this value again?

This is a good point. Some VCs were major proponents of this (and tons of other business people I'm sure), but this is of course just a guaranteed inflow into the largest companies and the companies that think they will be large some day. Yet another way to reallocate public cash to private companies.

Another similar example is UBI -- its proof of an economy that is not dynamic. It's a tacit approval and recognition of the fact that "no, you probably won't be able to find a job with dignity that can support you and your family, so the government will pay to make you comfortable while you exist".

replies(4): >>44478725 #>>44478933 #>>44481973 #>>44485796 #
mortsnort ◴[] No.44481973[source]
S&P 500 companies don't get any inflow of cash when their stock is purchased
replies(2): >>44483161 #>>44493553 #
1. snovymgodym ◴[] No.44483161[source]
No, but it makes the stock price appreciate which is even better than a cash inflow for an inside investor since your wealth increases without a taxable event.