←back to thread

207 points lexandstuff | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.202s | source
Show context
jandrewrogers ◴[] No.44477503[source]
A critical flaw in arguments like this is the embedded assumption that the creation of democratic policy is outside the system in some sense. The existence of AGI has the implication that it can effectively turn most people into sock puppets at scale without them realizing they are sock puppets.

Do you think, in this hypothesized environment, that “democratic policy” will be the organic will of the people? It assumes much more agency on the part of people than will actually exist, and possibly more than even exists now.

replies(7): >>44478486 #>>44478493 #>>44478695 #>>44479345 #>>44479418 #>>44479714 #>>44482752 #
foxglacier ◴[] No.44478493[source]
Normal human communication already does that. Do you really think almost any of the people who share their political opinions came up with them by being rational and working it out from information? Of course not. They just copied what they were told to believe. Almost nobody applies critical thought to politics, it's just "I believe something so I'm right and everybody else is stupid/evil".
replies(4): >>44478575 #>>44478742 #>>44480325 #>>44480474 #
drdaeman ◴[] No.44478575[source]
> Almost nobody applies critical thought to politics

Because they have different concerns, and time and attention are scarce. With all possible social changes like the article suggests this focus could change too. Ultimately, when things will get too bad, uprisings happen and sometimes things change. And I hope the more we (collectively) get through, the higher are the chances we start noticing the patterns and stopping early.

replies(2): >>44479134 #>>44483267 #
1. f6v ◴[] No.44479134[source]
> With all possible social changes like the article suggests this focus could change too.

I have an anecdote from Denmark. It’s a rich country with one of the best work-life balance in the world. Socialized healthcare and social safety net.

I noticed that during the election, they put the ads with just the candidate’s face and party name. It’s like they didn’t even have a message. I asked why. The locals told me nobody cares because “they’re all the same anyway”.

Two things could be happening: either all the candidates are really the same. Or people choose to focus on doing the things they like with their free time and resources. My feeling tells me it’s the second.