←back to thread

Introducing tmux-rs

(richardscollin.github.io)
858 points Jtsummers | 1 comments | 03 Jul 25 15:03 UTC | HN request time: 0.207s | source
Show context
usrbinbash ◴[04 Jul 25 13:04 UTC] No.44464175[source]▶
> the code base is now 100% (unsafe) Rust

So the primary (or rather: only) reason for using Rust over C (memory safety) is out the window.

> I’d like to share the process of porting the original codebase from ~67,000 lines of C code to ~81,000 lines of Rust

And the codebase got bigger.

So yeah, as the author explains, hobby project, and kudos to that, but nothing that I will install on any box of mine any time soon.

Besides, applications like tmux would much rather be prime candidates for a rewrite in a garbage collected systems language (aka.; Go) than in Rust. tmux spends 99% of its time waiting for the user to hit a key, there is nothing performance critical in such an app that wouldn't be 100% adequately served by Go.

replies(3): >>44464410 #>>44464533 #>>44471455 #
1. paddim8 ◴[05 Jul 25 09:48 UTC] No.44471455[source]▶
This is such a strange mindset. First of all, unsafe Rust is not comparable to C. It still has a lot of checks and balanced that C does not have. The author is also planning to make it more safe. And what do you mean "the primary reason"? The primary reason for this was to have fun. Let the man have fun.

> but nothing that I will install on any box of mine any time soon

Well, no one asked? I will never understand you chronically negative people that have to come in and whine about things that don't matter every time someone posts their fun little personal project that they made for fun. Have you tried being a little more positive? It makes life more enjoyable.