←back to thread

336 points tareqak | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.889s | source | bottom
Show context
me551ah ◴[] No.44470473[source]
I doubt if this will make much difference. Offshoring as a tactic emerged in the pandemic when companies realised that being “remote” works just as well.

Sure, foreign R&D still gets amortized over 15 years (NPV ≈59 % of a full write-off, so you “lose” ~8.6 % of your R&D spend in present-value terms, and only 6.7 % of the cost is deductible in year 1, creating a 19.6 % cash-tax gap). But offshore wages are often 50–70 % below U.S. rates:

• Even after the slower amortization drag, hiring at half the cost nets you ~30 % total savings on R&D headcount.

• On a pure cash basis you only need ~20 % lower wages to break even; most offshore markets easily exceed that.

• So the labor-cost arbitrage far outweighs the tax timing penalty unless your foreign salaries are less than ~20 % below U.S. levels.

In short: the 15-year amort rule hurts your tax deduction, but 50 %+ lower offshore wages more than make up for it.

replies(7): >>44470502 #>>44470560 #>>44470669 #>>44470673 #>>44471236 #>>44471284 #>>44471500 #
1. bravesoul2 ◴[] No.44471284[source]
Not convinced. Offshore has been possible since forever. Maybe IC cam be remote now. Your team can be global. US lead, 2 India based devs, 2 brazil devs. But not having this wasn't a blocker for saving money.

10, 100 or 500 people team in India who could work in the office together was possible forever.

It will change. I think once other countries become bigger investment centres. Not sure how yet though. US is a good potting soil for a startup because there is this huge addressable and free market. And the startup ecosystem. Then add in that most startups want WFO and minimum synced time zones... and for larger tech all that specialism is in house in the US.

replies(1): >>44471306 #
2. g0db1t ◴[] No.44471306[source]
Yeah, there's simply a lot of 'Muricans thinking programming and software dev. for some reason only can be done inside of the US.

As a EU senior dev I know zero senior devs making six figures pa - Go figure

replies(3): >>44471322 #>>44471395 #>>44471818 #
3. bravesoul2 ◴[] No.44471322[source]
I think there is game theory at play. I don't think Google for example is leaving money on the table. They hire worldwide of course but they are not swapping US for cheaper countries on mass and it must be for a good reason. Maybe it's a missed opportunity and some YC company dominates the new arbitrage. Who knows! I think I like the soil analogy. Moving the palm tree to another spot is risky if it's doing well in its current soil.
4. CalRobert ◴[] No.44471395[source]
It's not the heady days of 2022 but six figures shouldn't be impossible for someone with 10+ years of experience. But the trick is to (mostly) ignore the European companies and go for the American ones operating in Europe. Switzerland, Norway, and Ireland can be decent too.

I'm still stunned when I see what devs are paid in Germany and southern Europe though.

replies(1): >>44472052 #
5. kevin_thibedeau ◴[] No.44471818[source]
Six figures isn't special in the US for skilled tech workers. My starting salary as a college grad 25 years ago was an unremarkable $55K when dotcoms were slinging six figure salaries and options. That is now $102K.
6. FirmwareBurner ◴[] No.44472052{3}[source]
>I'm still stunned when I see what devs are paid in Germany and southern Europe though.

Are German wages really low? I thought Germany as the richest country in Europe.