←back to thread

Tools: Code Is All You Need

(lucumr.pocoo.org)
313 points Bogdanp | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
JyB ◴[] No.44455663[source]
> It demands too much context.

This is solved trivially by having default initial prompts. All majors tools like Claude Code or Gemini CLI have ways to set them up.

> You pass all your tools to an LLM and ask it to filter it down based on the task at hand. So far, there hasn't been much better approaches proposed.

Why is a "better" approach needed? If modern LLMs can properly figure it out? It's not like LLMs don't keep getting better with larger and larger context length. I never had a problem with an LLM struggling to use the appropriate MCP function on it's own.

> But you run into three problems: cost, speed, and general reliability

- cost: They keep getting cheaper and cheaper. It's ridiculously inexpensive for what those tools provide.

- speed: That seem extremely short sighted. No one is sitting idle looking at Claude Code in their terminal. And you can have more than one working on unrelated topics. That defeats the purpose. No matter how long it takes the time spent is purely bonus. You don't have to spend time in the loop when asking well defined tasks.

- reliability: Seem very prompt correlated ATM. I guess some people don't know what to ask which is the main issue.

Having LLMS being able to complete tedious tasks involving so many external tools at once is simply amazing thanks to MCP. Anecdotal but just today it did a task flawlessly involving: Notion pages, Linear Ticket, git, GitHub PR, GitHub CI logs. Being in the loop was just submitting one review on the PR. All the while I was busy doing something else. And for what, ~1$?

replies(2): >>44455696 #>>44455713 #
dingnuts ◴[] No.44455713[source]
> cost: They keep getting cheaper and cheaper

no they don't[0], the cost is just still hidden from you but the freebies will end just like MoviePass and cheap Ubers

https://bsky.app/profile/edzitron.com/post/3lsw4vatg3k2b

"Cursor released a $200-a-month subscription then made their $20-a-month subscription worse (worse output, slower) - yet it seems even on Max they're rate limiting people!"

https://bsky.app/profile/edzitron.com/post/3lsw3zwgw4c2h

replies(2): >>44455912 #>>44457639 #
1. fkyoureadthedoc ◴[] No.44455912[source]
The cost will stay hidden from me because my job will pay it, just like the cost of my laptop, o365 license, and every other tool I use at work.
replies(1): >>44456620 #
2. nativeit ◴[] No.44456620[source]
Until they use your salary to pay for another dozen licenses.