←back to thread

What to build instead of AI agents

(decodingml.substack.com)
233 points giuliomagnifico | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.199s | source
Show context
mindwok ◴[] No.44450569[source]
I'm not yet convinced (though I remain open to the idea) that AI agents are going to be a widely adopted pattern in the way people on LinkedIn suggest.

The way I use AI today is by keeping a pretty tight leash on it, a la Claude Code and Cursor. Not because the models aren't good enough, but because I like to weigh in frequently to provide taste and direction. Giving the AI more agency isn't necessarily desirable, because I want to provide that taste.

Maybe that'll change as I do more and new ergonomics reveal themselves, but right now I don't really want AI that's too agentic. Otherwise, I kind of lose connection to it.

replies(3): >>44450601 #>>44450841 #>>44451530 #
prmph ◴[] No.44451530[source]
Exactly. I made a similar comment as this elsewhere on this discussion:

The old adage still applies: there is no free lunch. It makes sense that LLMs are not going to be able to take humans entirely out of the loop.

Think about what it would mean if that were the case: if people, on the basis of a few simple prompts could let the agents loose and create sophisticated systems without any further input, the there would be nothing to differentiate those systems, and thus they would lose their meaning and value.

If prompting is indeed the new level of abstraction we are working at, then what value is added by asking Claude: make me a note-taking app? A million other people could also issue this same low-effort prompt; thus what is the value added here by the prompter?

replies(1): >>44451673 #
1. chamomeal ◴[] No.44451673[source]
I’ve been thinking about that too! If you can only make an app by “vibe coding” it, then anybody else in the world with internet access can make it, too!

Although sometimes the difficult part is knowing what to make, and LLMs are great for people who actually know what they want, but don’t know how to do it