←back to thread

Stop Killing Games

(www.stopkillinggames.com)
253 points MYEUHD | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.678s | source
Show context
andrecarini ◴[] No.44447202[source]
Lots of bad takes in this thread. The whole idea behind this is just to stop defrauding customers that buy your software and then are left holding the bag. Nobody is asking for developers to keep running server infra for eternity.

Any of the following options are enough to satisfy this proposal:

- Put an expiration date on the storefront and make it clear that your software is not guaranteed to continue working after date X.

- Have your server source code (stripped down of proprietary stuff) ready for public release at EoL.

- Allow customers to reverse engineer the binaries and communication protocol after EoL.

- Package dedicated server binaries with the game and allow customers to connect to it via a LAN or direct IP option.

replies(11): >>44447344 #>>44447371 #>>44447378 #>>44447435 #>>44447585 #>>44447716 #>>44447754 #>>44448408 #>>44448690 #>>44449028 #>>44449951 #
tiledjinn ◴[] No.44447435[source]
> - Put an expiration date on the storefront and make it clear that your software is not guaranteed to continue working after date X.

This software is not guaranteed beyond 0 Unix time.

> - Have your server source code (stripped down of proprietary stuff) ready for public release at EoL.

This isn't viable, and i would expect anyone on this site to understand that. it's roughly equivalent to saying "just make facebook stripped of proprietary code and ready for the public to run"

> - Allow customers to reverse engineer the binaries and communication protocol after EoL.

This is a reasonable path forward, but likely a non-starter in the US for political reasons. I understand that "stop killing games" is an EU thing.

> - Package dedicated server binaries with the game and allow customers to connect to it via a LAN or direct IP option.

See point 2. This is nonsensical.

replies(3): >>44447507 #>>44447532 #>>44448196 #
1. andrecarini ◴[] No.44447532[source]
Well, this is about software you bought in advance. The Facebook comparison doesn't really work because you're not paying in advance to use it.

> This software is not guaranteed beyond 0 Unix time.

Grandma goes to the store to buy a game for their grandkid. She sees two game boxes. One says in the front "This game will stop working tomorrow and you will not get a refund" and the other says "This game will stop working in 2030". Which one does she pick?

replies(1): >>44448362 #
2. tiledjinn ◴[] No.44448362[source]
Either the one little Timmy wanted, or the one the clerk tells her is selling fast (whether or not it's selling fast).