←back to thread

131 points Traces | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.944s | source
Show context
cucubeleza ◴[] No.44442748[source]
Brazilian government is dumb as hell, just tax everything and waste money with idiot things and a lot of corruption, tax the rich will make then flee to another country like Arab Emirates or USA, so more money for then, less for the country, extremely common L of the Workers Party
replies(1): >>44443126 #
1. mafuy ◴[] No.44443126[source]
So what do you propose instead, since you seem to figured it all out?
replies(1): >>44443266 #
2. cucubeleza ◴[] No.44443266[source]
cut unnecessary spending (Brazil has TONS of it), cut taxes, cut bureaucracies and not hide inflation like they do it's a good start. And you, what's your propose? You also thing that tax rich people will make the other side richer?
replies(1): >>44443506 #
3. alpaccount ◴[] No.44443506[source]
> cut taxes

Yep, this is absolutely correct. I don't see how people don't realize this, the simplest way to make brazil less unequal is to REDUCE tax!

From wiki: > The collection of federal taxes on the reserve base, shows that of the amount collected by the IRS of Brazil, the majority of the taxes are based on consumption, with approximately 53% on average of the funds raised by Revenue Federal Brazil and continue accounting for more than half of tax (52%) charged by the agency. This tax structure is even more perverse when we add the taxes collected at the state and municipal levels, which bring in the largest source of revenue. The tax burden on consumption is regressive. In Brazil those who earn up to twice the minimum wage spend 26% of their income to pay indirect taxes, while the tax burden for families with income higher than 30 times the minimum wage amounts to only 7%. Excessive taxation on consumption depresses demand directly affecting the economy, reducing the consumption of the middle and lower income families.

Taxing the rich will solve nothing (and let's be honest, this government is not aiming nor has the capacity to enforce it). Something much simpler is just let people be able to consume things, by removing taxes and cutting spending (probably not even necessary given how much the state already takes from its people).

Super simple, but, as usual, we love to overcomplicate it and play the popularity game.