←back to thread

139 points stubish | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
t0lo ◴[] No.44439390[source]
As an australian citizen i'm all for it. Look at how the internet and social media has destroyed our current youth and their naivety and sense of emotional security. They all act like they're living in soviet russia at this point and have become so hard and jaded.

Better I give a little bit of pii than some kid grows up too early.

Would you be able to tell the difference if this policy came from a place of compassion?

replies(3): >>44439429 #>>44439447 #>>44439466 #
abtinf ◴[] No.44439429[source]
> They all act like they're living in soviet russia

Nothing says “not living in Soviet Russia” like having to show your papers to access information.

replies(2): >>44439448 #>>44441750 #
jp0d ◴[] No.44439448[source]
what's the alternative? Is it really information or misinformation?
replies(4): >>44439462 #>>44439474 #>>44439478 #>>44439481 #
frollogaston ◴[] No.44439481[source]
I remember when any anti-Iraq-invasion material was considered "misinformation" in the US. Wonder how it went in Australia, since they were also very involved.
replies(1): >>44439536 #
defrost ◴[] No.44439536[source]
My recollection of the time is that most citizens that paid attention and a majority of the politicians in the UK and AU were fully aware the "intel" was sketchy and the motivations impure .. the debate was less about the information quality and more about the obligation to partner with the US in the invasion.

The UK PM and the AU PM backed the US position and sent troops in (in the AU case they even sent in advance rangers | commandos | SASR to scout and call targets from ground) but they were both aware the "justification" and WMD claims were BS.

replies(3): >>44439595 #>>44440785 #>>44440917 #
1. toyg ◴[] No.44440917[source]
The UK PM, Tony Blair, actually pushed the "45 minutes" fabrication. Some of his MPs might have been sceptical, but Blair was very clearly itching to be a wartime PM.

What you describe is more like the debate on continental Europe, which translated in little support (most countries provided help with logistics and minimal "peacekeeping").